Rajya Sabha MP Md Nadimul Haque’s supplementary questions on a) studies by the government to justify inter-GST slab commodities movements based on perceived-use characteristics, and b) steps to ensure a uniform taxation policy within a four-digit HSN code classification

Sir, in the General Budget discussions and also through a letter written by our hon. Chief Minister of West Bengal, we have asked whether there is a plan to scrap the 18 per cent GST on health and life insurance premium. This is very important. But my question is whether the Government, in its pursuit of enhancing GST compliance, has considered the disproportionate compliance burden imposed on businesses, especially SMEs, through measures such as mandatory ITC reversals linked to supplier credit notes and the ambiguity surrounding the taxability of vouchers. If not, what are the reasons for disregarding the operational challenges and financial strain these policies may create? My second supplementary is that currently, GST compliance is a nightmare for businesses due to the different and arbitrary tax slabs on various commodities. We saw an example of this when the hon. Finance Minister held an entire press conference to explain the difference in taxation on normal popcorn versus caramel popcorn. Please state whether the Ministry has any plans to reform the complicated GST structure by reducing the number of tax slabs, thereby ensuring ease of doing business, as has been done with income tax slabs.

Rajya Sabha MP Saket Gokhale’s supplementary question on improving the doctor-patient ratio on the eSanjeevani platform, and making doctors available exclusively for telecalls

Sir, the basic issue today with the eSanjeevani platform is the very dismal doctor-patient ratio. This results in calls queuing up. What happens in a lot of rural areas where they use eSanjivni platform is the network tends to be slow, connectivity tends to be slow. This result in a lot of people having the average wait time, according to one study in the Lancet, is about 20 to 25 minutes. The other problem, Sir, is a lot of doctors already have patients in their physical presence in the OPD. And, these are the same doctors who are consulting on the eSanjeevani platform. I am carrying to it, Sir. They are the same doctors who are to be consulted on eSanjeevani platform. They are already overwhelmed with the OPDs. So, the point is that it is a very good platform. What is the Ministry going to do to improve the patient-doctor ratio and whether you are going to get doctors who are specifically available only for tele-consultations on the platform?

Kalyan Banerjee’s speech during the General Discussion on the Union Budget for 2025-26

Sir, our country is always beautiful, developed and developing itself in each year after Independence in terms of heritage, culture, education, archaeology, mentality and role model of religious unity. India is widely considered as one of the best and oldest living civilizations with evidence of quality life and stable economy in the world dating back to at least 8000 BCE. Who will get the credit of this development and beauty each and every year? Who will get the credit? The people of the country will get the credit. It is due to the contribution of the people of this country, India has developed. No single person can claim that because of him, India has developed. To see whether any budget in the past few years has fulfilled the expectation of the people, the immediate test is the stock market’s response. Sensex and Nifty have maintained a flat benchmark in the stock market for the last 10 days and have not affected the market growth. Even real stocks, including RVNL, which would have been one of the biggest beneficial of the capex hike, have seen a significant decline of up to nine per cent following the Union Budget. This proves that the Budget for 2025-26 has neglected the challenge of the economy and the common demands of the people. It has not met the expectation of market participants leaving the common critical issues unresolved. With public debt at nearly 80 per cent of the GDP and interest payment consuming a quarter of Government revenue, this Budget is shocking and a fiscal betrayal to the people as well as strategic failure in driving economic growth. The Budget is anti-people and destructive for India’s economy. The Union Budget 2025-26 has failed to address several key economic challenges, including currency depreciation and declining markets. But it is a bold push towards the complete privatization of the economy. In 2014-15, the Government promoted a composite cap on foreign investment, raising it to 49 per cent, which has now been replaced by 100 per cent. The question is whether the entire population will be covered under insurance and medical insurance for availing treatment facilities at one-rupee premium cost or not. In 2019, the penetration of both life and non-life insurance in relation to GDP was 3.7 per cent, and it remains the same in 2024 due to absence of a peoplefriendly claim and policy mechanism. I have another crucial question regarding FDI in insurance and the Government’s policy on LIC and other public sector insurance companies. How long will they keep publicity secured and avoid disinvestment process? The GST has not been reduced in the insurance sector, while 100 per cent foreign investment is not allowed in the insurance sector. Our Chief Minister, the Chief of the Trinamool Congress, Mamata Banerjee ji, has been opposing FDI in insurance since 2012, and she stood against increasing the foreign investment cap in insurance sector to 100 per cent. She expressed her concern over the plight of people’s deposits in LIC and other public sector companies saying that the existence of such institutions might be at stake in future. Our hon. Prime Minister always speaks about reform, perform, transform, but he seems to be acknowledging what his Government has failed to do. The Budget ignores the immediate challenges of growing unemployment, inflation and inequality. The labour share of GDP dropped from 49 per cent in 2017 to 45.2 per cent in 2023. In terms of the 2025-26 Budget and the 2019-20 Budget, we can see that in 2019-20, borrowing and other liabilities were 20 per cent; they are 24 per cent now. The non-tax revenue, which was nine per cent, remains the same; custom duty was four per cent, which remains the same; corporate tax was 21 per cent, which is reduced to 17 per cent; GST was 19 per cent, which is reduced to 18 per cent; central excise duty was eight per cent, which is reduced to five per cent now; income-tax was 16 per cent which is now 22 per cent; non-debt capital receipts were three per cent which are now reduced to one per cent. In 2019-20, the interest payment was 18 per cent which is now 20 per cent; expenditure on centrally-sponsored scheme was nine per cent, which is now eight per cent. In 2019-20, the subsidies were eight per cent, which have gone down to six per cent. In 2019-20, the defence expenditure was nine per cent, which is eight per cent now; the expenditure on Finance Commission and transports was seven per cent, which is eight per cent now; other expenditure was eight per cent, which remains the same; expenditure on pension was five per cent which is reduced to four per cent; expenditure on the Centrally-sponsored schemes was 30 per cent, which is 16 per cent now. The data clearly shows that interest payment but not repayment of foreign loans, compromises with funding of Centrally-sponsored schemes, subsidies, pensions etc. The country’s external debt has risen to Rs.60.82 lakh crore in 2025 compared to Rs.39.50 lakh crore in 2019. A complete Budget in second term was addressed in 2019. Now they are delivering a complete budget in 2025. See how it has been reduced in their regime itself. Furthermore, loans and foreign borrowings are proposed to increase by two per cent, a move towards ridding with a huge debt. Before I go into other arena, I want to point out that in the recent past, I came to understand that the functioning of NCLTs and NCLATs are not in line with the objective of Code. The promoters are delaying the process directly or indirectly by making more litigations in the CIRP and liquidation proceedings. It is noticed that the NCLTs and NCLATs are not giving judgements in time. They are reserving the orders for months and months. I would like to know how many orders are reserved across India as on today, and for how many days, these orders are pending to be pronounced. What is the message the NCLT judges are trying to convey by holding these orders? Sir, by increasing the income limit for being taxed to Rs. 12 lakh, around one crore taxpayers, who were previously required to pay tax, will now pay none. The total expenditure as a proportion of the GDP is projected to decrease from the current 14.60 per cent to 14.20 per cent. Only 2.84 income tax payees will benefit from the income-tax exemption announced for next year. This is only 22 per cent of the total number of salaried workers in India and has no relevance to maximum working-class people of the country. Only 22 per cent of working class will get this benefit; rest of them will not get this benefit. The allocation to MGNREGA has been reduced to Rs.86,000 crore from Rs. 89,153 crore in 2023-24. A lesser allocation in MGNREGA and PMKisan scheme indicates stagnation. What will this budget do? The allocation for social service has been reduced by 16 per cent; housing funds have been cut by 4.38 per cent; and spending on social welfare and Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes has been reduced by more than three per cent. Most importantly, the Budget allocation for food subsidies has been reduced by four per cent. There is nothing for youth, women and farmers in this Budget. Regarding social sector spending, the total net receipts for the Centre are estimated at Rs. 28.37 lakh crore while the total expenditure stands at Rs.50.65 lakh crore, signalling continued fiscal constraint as on December 31, 2024. Sir, now I will speak about the Revised Estimate and the funds released. For Samagra Shiksha, fund estimated is Rs. 37,010 crore in 2024-25, released Rs. 17,605 crore. For AMRUT, the Revised Estimate was Rs. 6,000 crore, fund released was Rs. 4,158 crore. For Swachh Bharat Mission (Urban), fund estimated is Rs. 2,159 crore, fund released is Rs. 1,346 crore. For Jal Jeevan Mission, it has been reduced to Rs. 21,871 crore. With regard to the issue of unemployment, the economy requires 78.5 lakh new non-farm jobs every year, but there is no clear road map to achieve this. Sir, as reported by The Economic Survey, average monthly real earnings of self-employed men dropped from Rs. 9,454 and to Rs. 8,591 in 2023-24. If I read all the data, even in the agriculture field, everywhere, this is reducing. Now, I will speak about child development. These are the three important areas which I will look into. Around 35.5 per cent of children under five years of age are stunted. The maternal mortality rate is 97 per one lakh live births. Now, I will be talking about a very important issue which is appealing to my mind, that is the issue of women’s empowerment. The empowerment of women depends upon economic and financial independence. If the economic and financial independence of women are not there, there cannot be any women’s empowerment. What do we have to do? We have to take pathways to educate all the girl children of this country. Unless they are educated, women’s empowerment will be an unsuccessful slogan. From my political, professional and personal experience, I can say that the women of the country are really in danger now. Today’s result is not good. It is everywhere. The concept of marriage is almost gone. That bonding is not there. Everything is gone. Almost 70 per cent of women are divorced. They do not know how to maintain their livelihood. We have to do something for them. There should be an effort by everyone or rather, I will say to the girls and women of this country, through this House, to first stand up on their own feet and then think about marriage later on. Marriage is one of the requirements of life. I can understand that, but education is a compulsory requirement. I have only spoken for 10 minutes. Sir, it is required. We have to do it. We have to decide how we will do it. We have to do something for the women. We request you to kindly do it. Tourism is a significant boost to the economy. The Budget has allocated funds for the development of top 50 tourist destinations in partnership with the State Governments through a `Challenge Mode’, which is a positive approach. However, after spending over Rs 2,500 crore on the 45-day long Maha Kumbh Mela at Prayagraj, the Government has not taken a visible action regarding the massive and unfortunate stampede on 29th January, 2025. There is no clarity on the post-mortem reports, the number of deaths, compensation for the affected families or the issuance of death certificates. Why has the Central Government not taken any action or initiated inquiries into the negligence of the local State Government? You have made it an internal issue. It is no longer a State issue. You have advertised it widely. Why has the Kumbh Mela been made an internal issue? Why should there not be an inquiry by the Central Government itself? Why? That should be done. One JPC should be constituted by the Parliament to look into the unfortunate incident that occurred at the Maha Kumbh Mela. Now, I am come to the issue. The hon. Finance Minister has given much benefit to Bihar. We do not have anything to say. We have no objection. Bihar needs it; Bihar should get it. But why have you neglected Bengal? That is our question. No scheme has been introduced for the development of Bengal. Systematically, the Central financial benefits have been withdrawn from Bengal for one reason or the other without any foundation. In this background, I want to say that Bengal Global Business Summit, 2025 was held last week under the leadership of our hon. Chief Minister. A number of countries, 40-plus, attended the Summit. Some of the countries are Bhutan, Germany, Japan, Kenya, Malaysia, Morocco, and the United Kingdom. There were 40 countries. There were 16 sectoral sessions on different subjects. There were six country sessions with Bhutan, Japan, Germany, Poland, Malaysia and the Netherlands. There was an exhibition at Biswa Bangla Mela Prangan. There were 215 stalls covering key sectors. Top exhibitions were from the Government of Jharkhand, ITC, RPSG Group, Titagarh Rail Systems, ONGC, Jupiter Wagons, Patton International, Ambuja Neotia Group, Kolkata Port Trust, Manipal Hospitals, JIS Group, etc. Coming to the investment and impact, the total investment proposal that has come during the last two days is Rs.4,40,595 crore. I am not naming one big industrialist; I am speaking about a very famous, recognised, gentleman industrialist. I am not taking his name. He has said that Bengal is the place where the industry will be developed. Today’s industrial development of Bengal is because of Mamata. That he has said very categorically. We have seen it from his speech itself. I am not taking his name. He is not here. I am not supposed to take his name. Therefore, we have done so many things. We are having a crunch. No financial sanction is given from the Central Government either in MGNREGA, or in Awas Yojana or in anything. Everything is being done from the fund of the State Government. That is being done by the hon. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee. We can say that we do not mind if you ignore us. But for every ignorance of yours, people of Bengal will give answer every day. You will get the answer in 2026. Very nicely, you will get the answer in 2026 when the BJP will not get even 30 seats, will not get even an Opposition leader. I can assure you that if you neglect Bengal, people of Bengal will give you an answer. Now, journey will be done every day. The Prime Minister will go to Bengal. Then, Amit Shah will go. Then, Nirmala Sitharaman will go. Everybody will go to Bengal every day. But ultimately, they will not get even 30 seats. You ignore Bengal. The people of Bengal will give you an answer. BJP will get a big slap. Thank you, Sir.

 

Sushmita Dev’s speech during the General Discussion on the Union Budget for 2025-26

Mr. Vice-Chairman, Sir, I would like to start by thanking my Party for giving me the opportunity to speak on the Budget for 2025-26. I am honoured for two reasons as I am positioned very uniquely in this House. The first reason is that I come from a State in the North-East, my vote is in Assam, but 50 MLAs across Bengal have voted me into the Council of States. I thank my leader, Ms. Mamata Banerjee. The second and the more significant reason why I am positioned uniquely in this House is because when I look to my left and see so many Members of Parliament who come from the North-Eastern States, they tend to remain silent on all the ailing issues that the eight States of the North-East face. I feel lucky that when I look on this side of the House, when I look at the Opposition, I think, apart from Mr. Bhuyan, I am the only other Member of the Parliament in the Opposition. The silence on that side is killing – not a word on what happened in Manipur, not a word on what is happening in Assam and the NRC, not a word on the Nagaland Accord, not a single word of sympathy, not a single word of apathy. Sir, I would like to say that this Budget is an insensitive Budget; insensitive to the people of the country and more insensitive, in particular, to the North-East of India. I heard Prime Minister Modi say after the Budget that the sop that has been given to the middle class is going to have a multiplier effect. But, when it comes to the North-East, all the things that ail this nation, whether it is price rise, whether it is unemployment, whether it is lack of investment, the only multiplying effect that I know is that all these problems multiply as we go towards the North-Eastern States. I would like to say that it has consistently been the vision of the Government of India that they have given the States of North-East special status and special focus. Today, I recall, with a lot of respect and great tribute, our former Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh. It was his vision when he, in 1991, said that if we want the North-Eastern States to develop, then we have to Look East. What he meant was that the North-East was the gateway to the South-East and East Asia. It was a landlocked region of India and if it had to trade, if it had to create employment, if it had to attract investment, then we have to Look East. Whatever efforts were made by Dr. Manmohan Singh’s Government over decades have been undone by Prime Minister Modi by one single incident in one State, which is the State of Manipur. The Prime Minister Modi changed the Look East Policy to Act East Policy, but today, till the gateway to the South-East Asia, which is the State of Manipur, continues to burn, the Act East Policy is destined to fail. It is destined to fail, and I would like to say that today, with our security concerns with China, the political situation in Myanmar and the political situation in Bangladesh, I can tell you with great surety that the prospects of the economy of the North-Eastern States growing are rather dismal. I heard the hon. Finance Minister talk about Bihar. I heard the hon. Finance Minister talk about middle-class with the Delhi elections which were due. But, I never once heard the name of Manipur from the Finance Minister where 60,000 people have been displaced, where hundreds of people have been murdered and butchered and women raped and children who are out of schools. Thousands have fled from Manipur to different parts of India, whether it is Kolkata, whether it is Assam, whether it is Delhi. Today, what the Finance Minister should have said is not just Bihar, but she should have promised a comprehensive package for the rehabilitation of Manipur, which she did not. There should have been a comprehensive package because what happens to Manipur impacts all the North-Eastern States. Today, we cannot accept just a resignation of the Chief Minister as a solution to Manipur, and if the Manipur tapes are investigated, we will see, we will find out, and we want to know if it was State-sponsored mahyem that was created in Manipur. Now, I come to the cuts in the Budget. The nine lakh rupee Central pool of resources have been slashed by 30 per cent. The North-East Special Infrastructure Development Scheme’s allocation has been slashed by 39 per cent. Special development package has been slashed by 28.8 per cent. … Grants under PM-DevINE, that is, the Prime Minister’s Development Initiative for North East Region, have been slashed by 36 per cent. Grants to Autonomous Councils has been slashed by 96.6 per cent. Grants by Ministry of Home Affairs have been decreased by 45.6 per cent, and I can go on and on and on. When is this lip service to the North Eastern States going to stop, I want to know from the hon. Finance Minister? Madam, please tell us about ‘achche din’. Nobody knows about ‘achche din’. What happened to that? Then, we were all hoping for a ‘New India’. Nobody knows what happened to ‘New India’. Now, she says that our new destination is ‘Viksit Bharat by 2047’. I do not think, I will be alive and here in this Parliament to see what happens in 2047. Sir, I want to raise an important issue about my own State, the State of Assam. I thank the Government for giving us a urea plant. I have no problem with it, but this Government has systematically destroyed the public sector enterprises in the State of Assam. Two paper mills owned by the Hindustan Corporation have been shut down. We heard about ‘Advantage Assam’ from hon. Member of Parliament who just spoke before me, and, I want to say that more than 50 per cent of the investment that ‘Advantage Assam’ has attracted is from public sector undertakings and not private investment. Today, we hear that all the capitals of the North Eastern States will be smart cities. Let me give you just one example. Kalitaji is here. One flash flood in Guwahati, an eight year old boy falls from the scooter and gets drowned in the current of water! A flash flood caused it in Guwahati! Sir, the hon. Finance Minister talks about ‘Heal in India’ initiative and Medical Tourism. Medical tourism, for us in the North East, is that for small surgeries, for minimal treatments, we have to go to Chennai, Kolkata and Delhi. That is medical tourism for us in the North East. Let us talk about UDAN scheme. I come from a remote area in Assam called Silchar. I have been repeatedly saying it in this Parliament and I am pained to say that there is not a single route, I repeat, not a single route, from the Silchar airport which is recognized by UDAN. I ask myself why I want to say that it is a big slogan but this Government has to realize that without strong States, you cannot have a strong Centre. When is this Government going to realize this? Sir, the hon. Finance Minister said that she will start an index to see which are the States that are friendly to private investors. Please have an indicator of the States which you deprive, the States you deny, and the States which thrive despite that. I am talking about the State of West Bengal. Please add that indicator and you will see that West Bengal is ready, you will see that Mamata Banerjee has succeeded in Bengal not because of Modi Government but despite the Modi Government. Mr. Vice-Chairman, Sir, I hope, as Parliamentarians, we go beyond the headlines and look at the fine print to see that, in effect, it is an insensitive Budget which does not talk about unemployment, which does not talk about price-rise and which does not address the ailing and burning issues of this country. It is an absolute and total neglect of the North Eastern States and Bengal. Unless you rectify your ways, you will be routed from North-East and you will be routed from Bengal because, Sir, let me submit that today people are suffering and people’s voice in a democracy is the loudest voice. I can tell you that today Assam has got a urea plant and the one single reason is Assam is headed for elections, and Mr. Biren Singh has been asked to resign only because the entire tribal community of India has moved away from the Bharatiya Janata Party. With those words, I once again thank the party for giving me this opportunity. Thank you, Vice-Chairman, Sir. I wanted five more minutes. You should not be like a Finance Minister. Be gracious enough to give me five more minutes.

 

Derek O’Brien’s appeal to the Chair to ensure the microphone is not switched off during a speech by any Member, be it from the Opposition or the government

Madam, everyone is participating in the Budget discussion, and take one minute this way or that way. But what has happened today is that microphone has been switched off. These are very basic issues not to fight over. Somebody from that side may go over by one minute. We may go over by one minute. The Party has 45 minutes of time. At 45 minutes, we switch it off. Madam, with all respect to you, can you please ensure that this thing doesn’t happen? It is unbelievable that it has happened. His conclusion has been wiped off Just one minute. This is not a complaint. Madam, it is a good debate. Everybody is speaking. But, please, understand how we are feeling. The second largest opposition Party here with 13 MPs, with 40 minutes on our clock, our opening speaker’s mic is switched off! Somebody has to take care. And my appeal to you, through the Chairman, is not to make this happen again. Thank you.

 

Ritabrata Banerjee’s speech during the General Discussion on the Union Budget for 2025-26

Sir, I stand to make my speech, speaking on the Budget for the All India Trinamool Congress. As an MP from Bengal, this is a special time to be speaking. Last week, history was being made in my State. Captains of industry, thought leaders, heads of missions of 40 countries and leading entrepreneurs from across the world were drawn to Bengal for the two day Bengal Global Business Summit. Last week, many path-breaking projects were announced, from AI to tourism, from steel to energy to telecom. About a mammoth of Rupees four lakh plus crores in new investments and tens of thousands of prospective jobs made the headlines. One of the world’s biggest industrialists said this at the Bengal Global Business Summit in Kolkata- “Now Bengal is also witnessing a renaissance in economy and business… and no power on earth can stop Bengal’s resurgence.” Yes, Madam, Bengal means business. Now, let me dissect the below par Union Budget presented last week. India has more than 50 per cent of its population below the age of 25 years and more than 65 per cent, below the age of 35. Now the question is whether the country looks upon this population as a liability or as a resource. This is the basic question which the Budget must deal upon. In dark times, will there also be singing? Yes, there will also be singing; there will be singing about the dark times. The hon. Finance Minister has just left. The previous Budget presented by her in July 2024 after the Lok Sabha election had accorded priority to employment and skill development, given the nature of the election mandate. The Finance Minister had announced a Prime Minister’s package of five schemes and initiatives to facilitate jobs and internship opportunities for 4.1 crores youth over a five year period with a Central outlay of Rupees two lakh crore. However, this year’s Budget, February 1st, did not refer to the Prime Minister’s package even once. There is not even a single mention of the package. What do we learn? That the Cabinet note on employment-linked incentive scheme is under finalization and several meetings have been held with the Ministry of Labour and the CII to discuss the relationship between capital expenditure and employment generation. In other words, the future of the Scheme looks completely bleak. Now, the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS) – it is a Government data – revealed that in 2023-24, youth unemployment rate, for those aged 15-29 years, had gone up to 10.2 per cent and the unemployment rate among graduates was 13 per cent. The latest Economic Survey data shows that average real earnings of self-employed male workers in India have been decreasing constantly from 2017-18. There is a constant decline. The monthly real wage of male workers, salaried workers, is constantly declining. Surplus labour, inundating the job market, combined with high food inflation have severely squeezed the real incomes and livelihoods of an overwhelming majority of Indian workforce. For a Finance Minister and a Government always telling, Sabka Saath Sabka Vikaas, to overlook this is really, really dangerous. Modi Government’s mammoth * for the last 10 years, has taken a toll on our hard-earned public money. Over the last 10 years, frauds and corporate sharks frittered away; at least, Rs. 12 lakh crore of Rs. 16.11 lakh crore our banking system has written off. Out of this, the nationalised banks alone have written-off more than Rs. 12 lakh crore. When the hon. Finance Minister replies, I will urge upon that she must tell us, tell the House, how much of these written-off loans of nationalised banks have been recovered. Now, we could also compare this Rs. 16.11 lakh crore that has been written-off that disappeared over 10 years with the Union Government budgets for Education where the total expenditure was less than 40 per cent of this, and for Health, where it was less than half. To make up for this lost money, banks charge higher and higher user charges for every little service. The rates for loans go up because banks have suffered at the hands of frauds and fund-siphoning. Now, Madam, the stupefying increase in the wealth of the favoured 10 topmost cronies through favours, rule-tweakening and the low-value sale of high-value national assets during Modi’s Rule has been massive. But the ‘Rs. 12 lakh crore wipe-out’ by nationalised banks may help us understand how the next tier of cronies and beneficiaries gain from the regime. After all, our money in banks did not really disappear. They just hopped on to line the pockets of those who knew their way around in very complex, corrupt and dark times. Now, in 1956, both the Houses deliberated for three months. LIC was formed. The then Prime Minister of the country, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, gave from the corpus Rs. 5 crore for the formation of the LIC. The LIC started its journey. Today, LIC means 51,000 crore of rupees. LIC means 30 crore of policyholders. Now, you are allowing 100 per cent FDI. Allowing total freedom and greater access to foreign capital could only retard the orderly growth of the insurance industry with the focus more on profits rather than providing the people and business the much-needed security. Our hon. Chief Minister has written to the Finance Minister last year on August 2nd. She wrote a letter asking her to withdraw the 18 per cent GST on life insurance and health insurance policies. I quote from the letter, “With deep anguish, I am writing to you regarding the imposition of 18 per cent GST on life insurance and health insurance policies and the withdrawal of deductions. The GST is bad because it adversely affects the people’s ability to take care of their basic vital needs. This additional burden may be acting as a deterrent for many individuals from taking new policies or continuing their existing insurance coverage, thereby leaving them vulnerable for unforeseen financial distress.” Now regarding the withdrawal of the GST on health insurances, the Finance Minister is always shifting the onus to the GST Council. Madam, everybody is aware who is in charge of the GST council, who controls the GST council. It is the BJP-ruled States which have the majority in the GST council. Then what is stopping the Finance Minister and her party? The lack of political will is stopping them to roll-back this GST on health insurances. Madam, I was born and brought up in a refugee colony in the added areas of Kolkata. Migrated people, bearing the brunts of partition, had set up these colonies where from our adolescence we learnt that when politics determines our future, we must determine the politics. Political awareness runs in every blood and veins of Bengal in general and these innumerable refugee colonies in particular. Though I don’t have the first-hand experience of the horrors of partition unlike my father, still like many third or fourth generation refugee, I consider my refugee ancestry as one of my greatest badges of honour. This ‘refugee ancestry’ has passed on the political understanding of fighting for legitimate rights. As a trade union activist, fighting for the rightful dues of the working people becomes my duty. You are denying the people of their dues, denying the people of Bengal of their rightful dues. You are denying the MGNREGS workers. They are not in a begging mood anymore as they have realized that this denial is completely political. West Bengal owes a staggering figure of Rs. 1.75 lakh crores. The delay has not only affected the implementation of critical programmes but also created challenges for local governance, particularly, in rural areas that depend heavily on such funds for employment and infrastructure development. Madam, the fight for these funds is necessarily political. We are aware that we may be standing here, but if we shift our position and we shift to the other side, things will fall in place. But Bengal refuses to surrender. Bengal hates to surrender. Bengal will never surrender. Bengal will never bow down. I understand the problem of the Treasury Benches. You cannot fight Mamata Banerjee politically, you cannot match Mamata Banerjee’s good governance, you cannot match Mamata Banerjee’s welfare schemes and hence, you continue to deprive lakhs of our people. The more the deprivation, the sharper and greater will be our resolve, the resolve of our people to fight you in a befitting manner. The resolve finds resonance in the immortal words of the true polymath, who has been our greatest identity. *“It was the greatest Bengali of the last thousand years, Tagore, who said, “Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high; Where knowledge is free; Where the world has not been broken up into fragments by narrow domestic walls; Where words come out from the depth of truth; Where tireless striving stretches its arms toward perfection; Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way into the dreary desert sand of dead habit; Where the mind is led forward by Thee into ever-widening thought and action — Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake.” Now, Madam, as I am a trade union activist, I want to give this august House some important figures. I am not a student of economics, but these are very basic figures. When unorganized workforce in our country goes on increasing, the health of the economy is not in proper shape. Now, let me look into the figures that are available. Figures show that in Africa, 86 per cent of the labourers are in the unorganized sector while 14 per cent are in the organized sector; in Asia Pacific and Arab countries, 68 per cent are in the unorganized sector and 32 per cent in the organized sector; in the Americas, 40 per cent are in the unorganized sector and 60 per cent are in the organized sector; in Europe and Central Asian countries, 26 per cent are in the unorganized sector while 74 per cent are in the organized sector. And now, we now come to vishwaguru India. Let me tell the House, as a trade union activist, we are facing these problems. There are serious implications of this. Ninety-three per cent of the workforce has fallen under the unorganized sector; only seven per cent are organized workers. The organized workers definitely have some statutory benefits, but the unorganized workers are deprived of the statutory benefits. Fifty per cent of the contribution to the GDP of our country comes from the unorganized sector. Only six per cent of them are covered by social security measures. The blood, toil, sweat and tears of these workers are the bulwark of our economy. But the Budget has completly neglected them and has said nothing about them. Now, I want to mention about two schemes. One is the Pradhan Mantri Shram Yogi Maandhan Yojana, PMSYM, a Central scheme and the other is a State scheme of Bengal known as Bina Mulya Samajik Suraksha Yojana, BMSSY. Now, people from the unorganized sector who are covered by the Pradhan Mantri Shram Yogi Maandhan Yojana, PMSYM, have to contribute every month. They have to contribute money every month. In the BMSSY scheme of Mamata Banerjee, they need not contribute a single rupee; the entire money, from the age of 18 to 60 years, is given by the Government. Now, I come to flat figures. In the report up to January, 2025, in Bengal, the number of registrations of unorganized workers made under the Bina Mulya Samajik Suraksha Yojana of Mamata Banerjee is one crore and seventy-six lakh-plus. The number of benefits distributed is 34,94,000, almost 35 lakhs. The amount distributed is Rs. 2,606 crores. Let the Central Government show the political will, take up the responsibility and make the entire contribution for the workers, like Mamata Banerjee is doing, in the Central schemes. Now, Sir, I am a trade union worker and Mr. Prakash here stays in a tea garden in the northern part of Bengal. I will mention some tea-chronology that is very essential to mention here In 2016, when I was a Member of this House, hon. Finance Minister was the then Commerce and Industry Minister. This is the Gazette Notification. The Gazette Notification is dated 28th of January, 2016. Before that, the hon. Prime Minister had gone to Madarihat. He had promised about taking up some sick tea gardens. So, this Gazette Notification on 28th of January mentioned that Birpara, Garganda, Lankapara, Tulsipara, Hantapara, Dumchipara, Dimnima, seven tea gardens, will be taken over by the Tea Board. Within eight months, all these gardens got closed. And it was Mamata Banerjee and the Labour Department who took all the initiative of opening these tea gardens. 2016 was the Assembly elections of Bengal! Now come to 2021-22 Budget. In the Budget, thousand crores announced for Assam and Bengal tea gardens. I don’t know about Assam, but as far as Bengal’s experience is concerned, not a single penny has reached us. Now, this year, when the Budget has been announced, their tea imports are hampering us. Such problems like Central Government’s decision of plucking dates; damage of 7 per cent tea crop are also there. There is discussion in the tea garden. Common workers are discussing in the tea garden, ‘Oh, this year is 2025; so, in this Budget, nothing will come. Bengal’s Assembly election is in 2026. So, in 2026, definitely, you will have some promises, some jumlas, about the tea gardens’. But the results will come out in the month of May. Next year, when Mamata Banerjee becomes the Chief Minister of West Bengal for the fourth consecutive time, we will be back here in the House and we will not raise slogans. We will be raising people’s issues. Now, Madam, the fight against the anti-people policies will intensify. The fight against discrimination of Bengal will intensify. This regime will try to suppress all truth by all possible means. I will take half a minute, Madam. This regime will try to suppress all possible truth by all possible means. There will be conspiracies to bury Bengal into oblivion. But the boys of Bengal cannot be choked. The boys of Bengal cannot be stifled. The people of Bengal, under the leadership of Mamata Banerjee, will give a befitting rebuff to the anti-people policies. The fight against the anti-people policies will intensify. The fight against the discrimination of Bengal will intensify. This regime will try to suppress all truth by all possible means. There will be conspiracies to bury Bengal and Bengalis into oblivion. But, our voice cannot be choked. Our voice cannot be stifled. Bengal, under the leadership of Mamata Banerjee, will give a fitting rebuff to the anti-people policies of the Government. The people, united under Mamata Banerjee, shall always be victorious. Jai Bangla!

 

 

 

Dola Sen’s supplementary question in on why the handloom sector has been excluded from the PM Vishwakarma Scheme and why the scheme does not provide benefits to artisans above 60

Sir, through you, I want to inform the House that the State of West Bengal has the highest number of MSMEs owned by women and it has been appreciated by the concerned Ministry of the Union Government. West Bengal has secured the first prize for the best performance of MSMEs by the concerned Ministry of the Union Government many times in the last few years. I want to know whether the concerned Ministry of the Union Government is partial or blind to appreciate West Bengal ‘as such a low performer like West Bengal’? I want to know this, Sir, through you, from the concerned Minister. Why has the eco-friendly, environment-friendly traditional handloom sector been excluded by the concerned Ministry of the Union Government from PM Vishwakarma Yojana? Our State Government has already given at least Rs.200 crore towards the artisans of the handloom sector. Why does this scheme exclude the artisans of age more than 60? It is better they follow our Utkarsh Bangla, our Karmasathi, etc., which are getting the first prize for years in national and international arena. Thank you, Sir.

 

 

 

Saket Gokhale’s clarification to the Chair in about the Bengal government’s intention to send a letter to the Petroleum and Natural Gas Minister about the number of times permission for drilling in Ashoknagar has been denied by the Union government

Sir, I am not asking a supplementary. With your permission, I just want to make a point that as far as Ashoknagar is concerned, we will give a written statement to the hon. Minister about how many times the permission has been renewed and what his Ministry has been doing. But our request is, please ask him…

 

Derek O’brien’s Zero Hour mention on the need to preserve the coastal culture of Goa

Sir, smaller States rarely get a chance to have their voices heard here. So, I am happy today to raise the issue of the need to preserve the rich coastal culture of Goa. Sir, the coastal culture of Goa is basically made up of two communities. One is the fishing community with all their great traditions and the other is the toddy-tapping community. These are the two communities. Now, the vibrant communities in these fishing villages – I have been there once or twice and have seen myself – have a great tradition, but now they are going through an existential crisis, for a variety of reasons. It is primarily because of the CRZ, the Coastal Regulation Zones. As a result, these fishermen cannot build homes, cannot do up their homes, cannot park their boats and face all kinds of problems. Worse than that, the trawlers are coming and robbing them of their livelihood. So, the issue here is affecting 20,000 fishermen and about 1 lakh people in this community. Tough times for them! I want to quickly contrast this to what is happening for the fishermen in Bengal. There is a special scheme called ‘Samudra Sathi Scheme’ under which each fisherman gets Rs.10,000 for two months for off-fishing season. There is another scheme called ‘Matsya Jeebi Credit Card’. This is to protect the fishermen so that they do not get duped in a long-term institutional credit. These are the issues. There is also one more issue in Goa relating to salt pans. This is an old Goa tradition of using salt pans. From salt pans, they extricate salt. That too is under trouble. These should be preserved as heritage sites. We appeal to the Government to save the fishermen and to save Goa, as the Supreme Court said, ‘Do not turn it into a concrete jungle’. We must protect that. And what do the people of Goa do? What are the options they have? The last time when they voted, we were hearing slogans. There are two ways to use Zero Hour. One is, you can raise these issues or you can stand up and shout the slogans for your leader. I am using these issues. The Government of Goa is doing nothing. And what was the Opposition doing there? They elected 11 MLAs from the Congress in good faith. But eight Congress MLAs left and went to the BJP. So, who will protect the people of Goa? I appeal to this Government, leave the politics aside and let us get together to help the State.

 

Mohammed Nadimul Haque’s Zero Hour mention on the need to nurture All India Radio (AIR) to transform it into a world-class national broadcaster

Sir, India has a great tradition of cricket commentary on the radio. This Government is killing that tradition. In the years gone by, radio cricket commentaries had some legends, Berry Sarbadhikary, Pearson Surita, Dicky Rutnagur, Anant Setalvad, Kishore Bhimani and others. Why is Indian cricket commentary on radio now in such a poor shape? With the exception of a few commentators like Shri Sushil Doshi and Shri Vinit Garg in Hindi and Shri Sunil Gupta and Shri Prakash Vagankar in English, it is boring. There is a huge potential for Akashvani to create good content and reach larger audiences by producing world-class cricket commentary. The BBC and ABC only use the best commentators always. Akashvani is India’s national broadcaster. It has 591 stations, reaching 98 per cent of the population. With its massive reach, it has huge potential to lead in this space. In the first three months of 2022, Akashvani averaged just two crore listeners per month. The number of podcast listeners in India is estimated to be 17 crores. Still, the BCCI and channels don’t give radio rights to Akashvani. Yes, they deprive Akashvani. Terrible! And Akashvani does not even send commentators to the venues, citing lack of funds. On top of that, one cannot hear cricket commentary on the medium wave, but only on FM radio or via an App called ‘News on Air’. This is absurd, Sir. An excellent way to further grow Akashvani’s listeners’ base would be to create world-class cricket commentary. For this to become a reality, my Party, All India Trinamool Congress, suggests that three things must be done urgently. One, have dedicated channels for each language. Having the Hindi and English commentators doing the commentary, as a pair, is the surest way to kill good radio commentary. Two, the selection procedure of commentators for Akashvani is an opaque process. To create a pool of top-notch commentators is essential to have an impartial and professional judging system. Three, from the Akashvani panel of commentators, it is essential to select those who have a thorough understanding of cricket and the style to engage the listeners. There is little use slotting cricket commentators on the principle that every person on the panel has to be given a chance. Sir, I would like to suggest to the Minister to implement these three suggestions and appoint Shri Harsha Bhogle as the captain of a new team whose task would be to make Indian radio cricket commentary world class. Thank you, Sir.