Intervention by Sugata Bose during a discussion on Supplementary Demands for Grants

I take your point that we have to optimize our tax revenues both at the Central level and at the level of the State. However, you have correctly identified the problem that our economy is facing right now. There are two engines of growth – FDI flows and public investment in infrastructure.

You have conceded on the floor of this House several times and also today, that there is practically no new domestic private investment. Our captains of industry, our capitalist class had heavily invested in you, the BJP, during the election campaign but they are refusing to invest in India today. Now, if in fact, private investors remain in slumber and you have to make higher levels of public investment particularly for our infrastructure needs, this will have a bearing on the fiscal deficit that you just spoke about.

Therefore, I would like to ask you one question. You announced that you would have an Expert Committee to review the FRBM Act in the course of your Budget speech. Please take this House into confidence as to the status of that Expert Committee because we must spend both at the Central level and also in our States on the vital social sector schemes. We cannot ignore the poor and the downtrodden people in our State.

That is why, we say in West Bengal that we have such a terrible debt burden, yet we have an obligation and the responsibility to provide health, education and social infrastructure.

SS Roy speaks during Short Duration Discussion on the power of the Governor

Sir, with the imposition of President’s Rule in Uttarakhand, it became the 115th instance since 1950. All States except Chhattisgarh and Telangana had to face President’s Rule at least once. In this respect, according to the latest Home Ministry figures, made available through RTI application, UP leads the chart: in UP, President’s Rule was imposed 10 times, followed by Bihar with nine times, Kerala, Manipur, Punjab and Odisha with eight times.

Out of 115 times, Congress and Congress-led coalitions imposed President’s Rule 84 times, that is, 73% of the total number of such instances. The BJP or BJP-led Governments imposed President’s Rule seven times. And interestingly, the Janata Party Government (the BJP’s erstwhile outfit, the Bharatiya Jan Sangh merged with Janata Party) in power from 1977 to ’79, that is, two years, imposed President’s Rule 16 times, on some flimsy and unprecedented grounds.

Sir, all of us know that the makers of our Constitution, to some extent, followed Article IV Section 4 of the American Constitution while incorporating Articles 355 and 356 in our Constitution. Sir, the background is that in 1861, when Abraham Lincoln was the President of the United States, he had to face some internal disturbances on the issue of slavery and the South wanted to secede from the Union. That is why he wanted to use some sweeping powers to checkmate the situation, to arrest the situation. This is how Article IV Section 4 of the American Constitution came into being.

But our Article 355 and 356 are also patterned on Section 93 of the Government of India Act, 1935; the only exception being that, under the Government of India Act, 1935, it was the Governor or the Governor-General, now the powers are vested with the President of India.

Now, the Chairman of the Drafts Committee of our Constitution, Dr BR Ambedkar said – “In short, I share the sentiments that such Articles will never be called into operation and they would remain a dead letter. If at all they are brought into operation, I hope the President, who is endowed with these powers, will take proper precautions before actually suspending the administration of the provinces.”

Sir, We have not learnt from the lessons of Dr BR Ambedkar. Sir, in spite of the nine-judge Constitution Bench judgement of the Supreme Court in the SR Bommai case, no Government at the Centre had abided by the ruling of the Supreme Court and this is how the present Government has burnt its fingers intrhe case of Aruncahal and Uttarkhand.

Sir, insofar as the role of the Governors is concerned – because this discussion has two parts, one is Article 356 and the other is the role of the Governors – it seems that some of them act as agents or agents provocateurs of the ruling party at the Centre in some States. Sir, recent happenings in Arunachal and Uttarakhand have proved this once again.

Sir, now, ek Rajyapal, ek mahamahim Rajyapal, jab ki woh koi rajya mein Mukhya Mantri they, aur ek dharmiya dhancha ko giraya giya – who abhi doosre kahin Governor hain – unhone hamare national anthem ke khilaf publicly bol diya, disgraceful remarks he made against our national anthem in a public function. I made a petition to the Honourable President. I preferred substantial motion here in the House. Twice it was listed as ‘No-Day-Yet-Named-Motion’ during two sessions in quick succession – in the Budget Session and the Winter Session last – but the Government ran away from discussion. That motion was never taken up because I wanted to tell this august House that how a Governor, who has taken an oath under the Constitution, can question our national anthem; they have gone to that extent also.

How these people are appointed as Governors? This is why my party, All India Trinamool Congress, demands that Article 157 of the Constitution, which deals with the appointment of the Governor, must be reviewed and more specific and broad criteria and /or eligibility and/or qualification must be provided in the appointment of Governors if we at all want that this institution should continue.

Sir, to conclude, I would like to refer, with your permission, to one short point from a consultation paper on Article 356 of the Constitution by an Advisory Panel of National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution. So, it is a Government document. From this Government document I want to refer to only one point, my last point, and then I will conclude:

“We therefore think it advisable to suggest that Article 356 be amended to provide for the following” (there are many suggestions; I am placing only one suggestion here) – “whether the Ministry is a State has lost the confidence of the Legislative Assembly or not should be decided only on the floor of the Assembly and nowhere else. If necessary, the Central Government should take necessary steps to enable the Legislative Assembly to meet and freely transact its business. The Governor should not be allowed to dismiss the Ministry so long as it enjoys the confidence of the House. Only where a Chief Minister of the Ministry refuses to resign after his Ministry is defeated on a motion of no-confidence, should the Governor dismiss the State Government.”

Therefore, even the ruling party at the Centre, did not have any respect for the provisions of the Constitution, for the spirit of the Constitution, on what the Constitution-makers, particularly Dr BR Ambedkar, while drafting the Constitution, had given warning that you should be treated as a dead letter. The dead letter has been alive for 115 times since 1950. If we do not put a stop, it will continue for an indefinite period. The time has come that this august House must decide on this issue.

Yeh tu-tu main-main karne se kuch hone wala nahin. kabhi idhar khushi kabhi udhar gham, kabhi idhar gham udhar khushi. Yeh silsila nahin chalna chahiye. Is mein thora end lana chahiye. Is liye mein aap se nivedan karta hoon, hamare sabhi Honourable Members se, is gambhir vishay ko aur bhi charcha kare, vistar se charcha kare, aur isko review kiya jaaye whether Article 356 should be there or not, and whether the Governors, who are essentially the agents and agents provocateurs of the ruling party at the Centre, should be appointed in the States to curb the democratic elected Governments’ activities.

It must come to an end.

This is my humble submission to this august House on behalf of All India Trinamool Congress.

Thank you, Sir.    

Centre talks of cooperative federalism but practices camouflaged centralism: Abhishek Banerjee

Trinamool MP from Diamond Harbour constituency, Abhishek Banerjee, who is also the President of Trinamool Youth Congress, today slammed the Centre during a discussion on the supplementary demands for grants.

Taking a dig at the central government, he said while they talk about cooperative federalism, they practice camouflaged centralism. He also slammed them for being busy in headline management, so much so that there was total mismanagement.

He also said that anger was rising against the current government and there was no achhe din in sight for the jawans in Kashmir or the farmers in Kanyakumari.

Highlights of his speech:

 On massive victory for Trinamool in Bengal

 I rise here today with pride and dignity, with my head held high representing my state and its people who chose truth over lies & hype. Two months ago, the people of my State had three choices.

One, an ideology-less / unethical / venomous alliance.

Two, a party that runs on media hype & encourages religious fundamentalism.

And three, the Trinamool Congress, which worked for development, peace, prosperity and communal harmony. The choices were clear. And the people spoke Loudly. Clearly.

Silence on Dalits and Kashmir

Now let us look at the promises made by the Central Government. A Government that speaks about ‘cooperative federalism’.A Government that talks about strengthening the Centre-State relationship.A Government that tweets on every subject, but remains silent and mum when Dalits are killed and young minds in Kashmir are pained.

This Government often speaks about ‘competitive federalism’. About States competing with each other to perform better. But in the past two years, cooperative federalism has merely been a slogan. An empty slogan, not the reality.

Camouflaged Centralism

The CM of West Bengal wrote to the PM in April-May 2015 detailing the ways in which the Centre was short-changing the States. There has been no positive response.

From this Government’s record, it is clear that there is no cooperative federalism. There is no competitive federalism. Madam/Sir, indeed no cooperative federalism…what we have, is what I call… CAMOUFLAGED CENTRALISM. Yes, camouflaged centralism.

There has been talk of fiscal transfers to the States. But the reality is different. Allocations for 39 major schemes have been withdrawn and 58 key welfare schemes have been scaled down. Also, 8 programmes that had Central funding have been cut.

West Bengal is being weighed down by a massive debt of more than Rs. 3 lakh crore left behind by the previous dispensation. Other States like Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh also have debt in excess of Rs. 2 lakh crores. Has there been any waiver? Has there been any support? Has there been any debt relief? Has the Central Government taken any initiative to reduce the debt burden or truncate the same???

Is this cooperative federalism?  NO!

The Planning Commission has been abolished and the States have lost an important platform to raise matters. You call an Inter-State meeting of Chief Ministers but decide the agenda without consulting anyone. You give Chief Ministers time to speak based on the colour of their party flag.

Bengal’s performance

  1. Inflation

In the Supplementary Demand for Grants, Rs. 40,000 crore has been allocated as Ways and Means Advance to the Food Corporation of India. Given the inflation situation in the country and the crucial role of the Public Distribution System for the common man, it is not clear why this allocation was not made during the Budget Session and is coming up at this stage.

Bengal has the lowest inflation rate in the country, less than 3%, according to the latest Economic Survey published by the Central government. The inflation rate for the entire country is 5.7%. From day one of this Monsoon Session, my colleagues from Trinamool have been strongly raising this issue of price rise both inside and outside Parliament.

  1. Let’s take MGNREGA

The BJP has always criticised MGNREGA as a failure and have ridiculed it as a scheme for ‘digging holes’. This is reflected in the scheme’s overall performance. The average days of employment per household has been dismal, below 50 days per year. Last year, it was only 34.84 days per year. In Bengal the story is different. MGNREGA aims to provide at least 100 days of wage employment per year. 85 lakh person-days of work has been generated and we have spent Rs. 18,000 crores towards the scheme in the past years. Again, the best in the country.

This Demand for Grants adds Rs. 5000 crore to the MGNREGA fund. This is a good step but again, it is not clear why such an important allocation is appearing as a Supplementary Demand for Grants.

  1. As for financial growth, the Gross Value Added Growth of Bengal is at a 12.02% high while India is at 7.3%.
  1. One example from social and rural development.

The Centre’s budget for BetiBachaoBetiPadhao, a scheme that was modelled and repackaged on West Bengal’s Kanyashree scheme, is a mere Rs. 75 crores. I wonder how much of it went into newspaper ads and social media campaigns. What is the budget for the Kanyashree scheme in West Bengal today? More than Rs. 1000 crores.Almost 10 times more than the Centre for just one State. That’s Bengal for you!

  1. Minority development.

Madam/Sir, let the facts and figures speak for itself. Let’s look at the numbers. The Budget increased four times in five years in Bengal. And what have the Centre done? Can’t even run a portal to distribute minority scholarships. But then do they care about minorities? Do they care about the oppressed? Do they care about the farmer? Do they really care?

State of West Bengal still has a GDP that doubled from Rs. 4.61 lakh crore in 2010-11 to Rs. 9.20 lakh crore in 2015-16.

Total mismanagement

This is a Central Government who believes they are an event management agency. They create big ads with big promises. Write catchy slogans. Make lots of noise. Try and do headline management. But the result is total mismanagement.

Changing lives of people

When you want to change the lives of people, how do you do it?

  • You change lives by setting up fair price shops selling medicines with up to 70% discount
  • You change lives by giving proper shelter and houses free of cost to economically weaker section of people under the GEETANJALI scheme.
  • You change lives by making districts across the State “Open Defecation Free”
  • You change lives by electrifying households under the SabarGhareAlo scheme
  • You change lives by giving 45 lakh SabujSathi cycles to girls and boys, so a 50-minute walk to their school becomes a 5-minute ride.

Anger rising against the government

As for the BJP-led NDA government, all you have given the country so far are Achhe Slogans, Achhe ads, Achhe tweets. Achhe Sapne aur Achhe Jumley. 25 mahina baad ek asha aur umeed ki kiran le kar jo achhe din ke sapne dekhe the…Woh har hindustani aaj jaanna chahta hai yeh achhe din kab ayenge? Kashmir mein border par khada hua jawan yah Kanyakumari mein rah dekh raha Kisaan kisike bhi achhe din nahi aye… Sir, baatein bahut huyi lekin desh ki zamini haqeeqat mein koi badlav nahi aya.

 

 

The image is representative

Ratna De Nag speaks of augmentation in the service of EMU coaches in her constituency

Thank you very much Sir.

There is a need for augmentation in the service of the EMU coaches in all sections under Howrah division of Eastern Railway.

There is also a need for introduction of new pair of EMU coaches for Katwa-Sealdah route in the morning and Sealdah-Katwa route in the evening so that the pace of the rail transformation is enhanced and grievances of the people are addressed seriously.

This place is an agricultural and industrial belt inhabited by the business people who depend mainly on train transportation.

So, through you, Sir, I would like to ask the Hon’ble Minister to look into this matter on priority basis and instruct the authorities to take the necessary action.

 

Pratima Mandal demands railway connectivity in Kultali during Zero Hour

Thank you Hon’ble Deputy Speaker Sir, for giving me an opportunity to speak during Zero hour.

Sir, my parliamentary constituency is Joynagar.  Under this parliamentary constituency Kultali is commonly known as Sundarbens area because small part of Sundarbens falls under this block and surrounded by Thakurain, Bidyadhari Muni river.

Sir, we are going to celebrate the 70th anniversary of our Independence Day but this block has no rail line. The people of this block are getting deprived of railway connectivity. So, I would like to request the Hon’ble Minister that he should ask his department to conduct a survey for this block. He should consider the demand for railway connectivity in Kultali.

Aparupa Poddar speaks during Zero Hour on the issue of funds for police modernisation

Thank you Deputy Speaker Sir.

Police modernization has been taken out from the list of centrally-funded schemes because of which West Bengal will suffer, specially in Jangalmahal and Hill areas. Chandrakona in Paschim Medinipur district partly comes in Jangalmahal area which falls under my parliamentary constituency of Arambagh; it consists of people from weaker sections of the society.

Since national security is dependent on police modernisation, central government has to allocate funds to the State Government. Bengal should be given full A category status, Hon’ble Chief Minister has already written to Centre regarding the allocation of funds. Hence I urge the Hon’ble  Prime Minister to instruct the Home ministry to act upon this demand and do the needful for the betterment of the public.

 

Tapas Pal speaks the river bank erosion of Ganga river in Krishnanagar

Sir, I would like to bring to your notice that river bank erosion of Ganga several areas in my Krishnanagar constituency are getting damaged. The areas include Tollygunge block, Matiari tipi, Dhubulia block 2, Rajapur, Shankarpur, under Belpukur GP, block Dhubulia 2, Sadhanpara 1 GP, Rukunpur.

Many houses are damaged and lives of several people are at risk. We want the hon. Minister to take some action regarding this matter. Please address the tears of the poor people.
Thank you, Sir.

Mamata Bala Thakur speaks on the issue of safety of female passengers on the Bonga-Sealdah railway route

আপনাকে ধন্যবাদ এবং আমাদের মা-মাটি-মানুষের দলনেত্রী মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়কে ধন্যবাদ জানাই। বনগাঁ-শিয়ালদা ভারতবর্ষের ব্যস্ততম রেল পথের মধ্যে একটি অন্যতম। এখানে প্রতিদিন লক্ষ লক্ষ লোক জীবিকা অর্জন এবং বিভিন্ন কারণে আসা যাওয়া করেন। কিন্তু দুঃখের বিষয় উক্ত রুটে কম সংখ্যক ট্রেন থাকার দরুন এবং তা সময়মতো না থাকার জন্য যাত্রীদের প্রতিদিন নাজেহাল হতে হচ্ছে। ট্রেনে এত ভিড় হয় যে ওঠানামার সময় যেকোনো মুহূর্তে দুর্ঘটনা ঘটে যেতে পারে। উল্লেখ্য গত বছর মাতৃভুমি ট্রেনের কথা বলা যেতে পারে।

স্পিকার মহোদয় আপনার দ্বারা মাননীয় রেল মন্ত্রীর কাছে মহিলাদের সুরক্ষার জন্য অনুরোধ করছি।

মহোদয়, বনগাঁ-ঠাকুরনগর ভারতবর্ষের মধ্যে ফুলের অন্যতম মার্কেট হওয়ায় এখানে প্রতিদিন লক্ষ লক্ষ লোক জীবিকা অর্জন করার জন্য আসেন। যার মধ্যে মহিলাদের সংখ্যা বেশি।

এনারা ভোর ৩ টের সময় উঠে ব্যবসার জন্য লেগে পরেন কিন্তু দুঃখের বিষয় ভোর ৩টে থেকে ভোর ৪ টের মধ্যে মাত্র একটি ট্রেন থাকায় অসম্ভব ভিড় ও চাপের মুখে পরে মহিলাদের কষ্ট করে যাতায়াত করতে হয়।

অতএব মাননীয় রেল মন্ত্রীর কাছে আমার একান্ত অনুরোধ যে যদি ওই সময় আর একটি ১২ বগির অতিরিক্ত ট্রেন চালু করা যায় তাহলে ভালো হয়। এছাড়া যারা অফিসের কাজে সকাল ৮টা থেকে ১০টার মধ্যে যাতায়াত করেন এবং বিকেলে ফেরত আসেন, তাদের জন্য বিশেষ লক্ষ রাখতে অনুরোধ জানাব।

 

ধন্যবাদ।

Saugata Roy speaks during Question Hour on renovation of Ganga ghats in Bengal

The Minister spoke at length about the Mission but did not say a word about any project for West Bengal. The river Ganges flows for about 400 km in West Bengal, as far as I know. Ganga flows from Manikchak till Gangasagar in our State. But the Minister is silent on Bengal.

In my constituency there are four municipalities on the banks of river Ganga. In three of those municipalities we renovated the ghats during UPA 2 time. We have been writing letters for the last two years for the renovation of Baranagar ghat and setting up electric crematorium there. The Minister only acknowledges the letters but has not taken any concrete action.

The Minister mentioned 6 cities, five of which are in UP and one in Bihar. What about rejuvenation of Ganga in West Bengal? Will the Minister please shed light on that. This is my question.

 

Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar speaks during a short duration discussion on sustainable development goals

Thank you Hon’ble Sir for giving me the opportunity to speak on this very important topic that is plaguing the world today. I stand here as a member of All India Trinamool Congress. We are actually standing at crossroads today whether to be a developing nation or not.

Certain nations have been developing at a faster pace than ours over the last centuries and they have also been major contributors towards the green gas emission. Their carbon footprint has also been much more than ours. When we take up the task of development, load of sanctions and interjections are being placed before us and we as a developing nation are facing this problem now.

So as my Hon’ble Chief Minister Smt Mamata Banerjee has rightly pointed out that with perspective to India the NGT has to be prudent in their restriction towards our development projects and refrain from overzealous actions.

I take this opportune moment to extend gratitude to the leaders of 193 countries who during the General Assembly Session of the United Nations in September, 2015 got together and took serious cognizance of this burning issue to strike a balance between growth and development of the nations and also to maintain nature environment to protect our planet.

Five things are involved in this total effort – people, planet, peace, prosperity and partnership between nations. The sustainable development goals were worked upon on the millennium development goals, eight of them were there, and we have done quite well.

And depending on that we have worked upon the SDGs which also involves the environment. MDGs did not take into cognizance the environmental factor but here we want to maintain the environment like all of us who are born from one mother, we have only one world. And to leave this world for our posterity we must protect the world.

Even if we are trying to develop in different fields we have to take care of our planet, of our nature, of our water bodies, and the SDGs have taken into consideration. This is the first time that all the nations first got together, discussed and then formulated the seventeen goals and 169 targets, that we are going to undertake over the next 14 years up to 2030 to meet our needs.

It is already coming to effect from first of January this year. And unlike many previous decisions the world together in consultation has drawn this up. It was not due to any regional decision, It was not due to any national decision, it was rather a quantitative decision dealing not only with human or the planet separately. Ecological sustainability was seen as an element of economic development.

The problems were taken to be universal and interconnected because the air quality getting disturbed over my country will go and affect another country. But in doing so we also have to take into consideration that we are growing, we are developing and we must be given more opportunity. The first six goals for MBG which were for poverty allegation, has been repeated here also. We the developing world need industrialization but we have to be protective towards mother earth.

On behalf of the people we serve we have adopted a historic decision on a comprehensive, far-reaching and people-centric set of universal and transformative goals. We are committed in achieving sustainable development in these three dimensions of economics social and environmental development to build upon the MDGs. But most important would be policy making.

When we are discussing it here today, budget allocation should be made towards meeting these 17 goals and 169 targets and we have to strike a balance. The developed world has been a major contributor towards polluting our water bodies, our air quality, depleting our forest, starting the practice of newer food techniques and we have followed suit and have forgotten our traditional foods.

Yesterday Hon’ble speaker had organized a meeting regarding SDGs, and there an honorable member was pointing out the present situation in which the current generation does not even recognize traditional foods like jawar and bajra for nutrition; we are dependent on packed foods. We are preparing them, packing and then marketing them; this involves artificial methods and energy consumption which is not good for the planet, we have to go back to our natural resources.

Six of the 17 goals here involves disaster risk reduction, recognizing the reduction of vulnerability of exposing the poor to diseases is important for sustainable poverty reduction. Out of the 17, the first one is poverty eradication. Poverty and environment are closely relates, especially when people depend for the primary source of livelihood on the environment.

Restoring natural systems and improving natural resource management practices at the grassroots level are essential to the strategy to eliminate poverty. Diversion of common and marginal lands to a more economically viable so to say useful purposes deprives the poor off a resource base which has traditionally met many of their sustenance needs, like the right of the forest should be with the people who live in the forest since ages are known. We should give them the power to live in the forest, to use the forest as their own to the adivasis and tribals who have been living there instead of cutting the trees and giving away the wealth of the forest, giving away the mines and minerals of the forests to multinationals.

Market factors also lead to the elimination of the crops that have traditionally been available to the diet of the poor. Here I would like to point out that these days baby food and prepared food is taking a serious toll on the health of the children. If the babies are breastfed, they are saved, they are protected from reproductory tract diseases, they are protected from diarrheal diseases. It is known that according to a very important study in the medical journal of Lancet breastfeeding can save 820000 lives annually preventing 13% of deaths of children under 5. Breastfeeding could reduce one third of the respiratory diseases, for India it could reduce 156000 child deaths each year. It would reduce maternal deaths of cancer, breastfeeding forms a natural contraceptive towards maintaining family size and it would also help prevent the lady from getting breast cancer or that of the reproductive tract; 4300 crores improved as far as the IQ of the child is concerned for a child who is breastfed. Not only that, the proprietary preparations that are marketed by different companies at the moment, they sell milk formulas at the moment which emit 111226 tonnes of greenhouse gasses. So many countries are encouraging mothers towards breastfeeding.

The United Nations is laying stress on infant and young children’s feed. There are reports that many children who have feed fed on formula milk remain stunted in growth, in chronic hunger and their IQ is not optimally developed. Not only that, due to greenhouse emissions during preparation, it generates carbon footprints. The industrially manufactured milk formula adds greenhouse gases at every step of production, transport and use, and it gives rise to wastage also.

One of the sustainable development goals, the second one, is regarding the food that developed nations throw away; but the under-developed nations go hungry. There are many people in the under-developed nations, to be specific, one in every nine children, who go to bed hungry. But every day, the food wasted in developed nations is 4,896 crore kilograms. These food materials, which are used as landfills, gives rise to methane gas, which again causes global warming. And this food wastage is at its highest in the United States where, about 80% of the people who are throwing away the food say that they feel guilty while throwing the food on their plates but that they cannot help it.

I think, while we are discussing the SDGs, we are here to draw policies, how we can work towards attaining the SDGs. The policy should be to not to throw away food. We should actually make it a stylish slogan in the society. There should be a slogan, ‘Grow more food, don’t throw food.’

Each one of us should try to grow a little bit of what we eat. I can proudly say that I don’t buy vegetables for my family, I grow it myself. Everybody might not be having land to grow enough for the whole family but every balcony, every rooftop can house earthenware pots where not only you grow your vegetables in little amounts but where you can actually make manure or compost from everyday household waste like vegetable peels and wasted food matter. It can be just turned into compost and used as manure. So the slogan should be ‘Grow food, don’t throw food.’

And not only for India – it should be globally accepted; everyone must grow a little bit to contribute to the nation, to the international community, to the planet. And we have to take into consideration that a major thrust at the policy level is necessary to ensure equity and justice for us.

Then the next SDG is education. I am proud to say that my leader, Mamata Banerjee, the Honourable Chief Minister of West Bengal, started Kanyashree in which she has allotted Rs 1,500 crore, not a paltry Rs 100 crore, and 32 lakh girl children are being empowered. And she is giving them non-polluting vehicles in the form of cycles to paddle to school, because this paddling of cycles is not only allowing the girl to go safely to the school and come back, but the very effort of paddling the cycle is creating a proper cardiac output by which she will never get hypertension, she will never get diabetic, she will never have a heart attack, when she grows up. So this is the foresight of my leader, Mamata Banerjee. I think we should all accept and adopt these methods to create a sustainable development because a cycle is a non-polluting vehicle.

With perspective to India, 15% of homes are lit by kerosene. As far as industry is concerned, we are using fossil fuel. As far as production of electricity is concerned, we are using fossil fuel. And even for the lighting up of our homes, we are using kerosene. It is a polluting agent. It is disturbing the atmosphere. So we have to shift towards renewable and clean energy. But my personal experience is, I have allocated a lot of money from the Members of Parliament Local Area Development (MPLAD) fund towards street lighting through solar power, but after two to three years there is no after-sales service. There is nobody to take care of the batteries. So once they stop working, there is no way by which we can take them forward.

The present Government has started the Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Yojana in which vocational training is being given to young children, young dropouts. I would request the Government to train these young students to maintain the sources of renewable energy, the equipments of renewable energy and non-polluting equipments, so that they become a good workforce and maintain these renewable energy equipments for use for a very long time.  

With the increase in purchasing power, wasteful consumption linked to market-driven consumerism is stressing the resource base of developing countries. So that we should go back to a traditional way of living in the fashion of our father of the nation’s teachings, for simple living.

We have to realize whether this is technology push or market pull that the nations today are responding to, the new generation is responding to. If it is only the technology push then dialogue through policy making would have to be started with the multinational who are forcing our youth to follow paths which are forcing them to buy equipment which are polluting.

Out of these different SDG goals agriculture is very important because it involves land use and water use. We should make available water for agriculture even to the remotest villages. We should start practicing multi-crop culture and have a proper land use policy. And depletion of land should be taken care of by scientists who can ensure nitrogen fixation by alternating crops with leguminous crops; this will not only will bring down the price of Dal as it is now but the legume will also stabilize the nitrogen of the soil.

The biomass which will continue for a long time to be a major source of fuel energy especially for rural poor, you are not actually being able to help them. Biomass will form their major source. But there are two kinds of biomass usage for combustion. The cow dung cake is polluting and it is also increasing in price at the moment. But the Gobar Gas is not; that should be made universally available to the rural poor.

The significance of the diversity in nature must be realized, must be appreciated and taught in schools because we need to protect and preserve our Earth. There is a strong relationship between health and the state of environment and employment. Because, the workers of asbestos, silicon and mines get silicosis. They are dying of lung diseases. So we have to give them a proper healthy atmosphere to work and earn living.

The overseas assistance is declining and the commitments industrialized countries gave in the Earth Summit a decade ago are mostly unmade. We have to turn our attention towards that. Environmental and social clauses which have been made implicitly or explicitly part of international agreement, must not be used selectively to erect trade barriers against us. We have to take this up at international forum. Mechanism must be put in place to make latest technology available to developing countries at reasonable cost. And mainstream education should include science and children should be taught basic science so that they know about the future. If they do not preserve this earth they have no home.

 

Thank you, Sir.