Whenever I start a movement, there is criticism, I am used to it : Mamata Banerjee Interview

Leading the charge against the Centre’s move to demonetise high-value currency notes, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee spoke about the reasons for her protest and the Army’s presence in her state.

There is a lot of criticism from the BJP and others who are saying that you are seeing conspiracies where there are none. What is your reaction to this?

Whenever I start a movement, there is criticism. I am used to that. When I began the movement against the Left, with Jyoti Basu as Chief Minister, I was criticised. I was attacked by the Left. Later, when I began the movement in Singur, I was similarly attacked and criticised. This is the same thing.

But whatever the common people feel, that is the truth that matters. People know that this move of demonetisation is a black move by a black government. People will respond to note-bandi with vote-bandi.

What is the next step in your protest against demonetisation?

We are going to continue our opposition against the Modi government and demonetisation. I believe in constructive criticism and the opposition needs to be united. But already, the BJP has no one speaking in favour of them. All these economists, it is not like they know me. But they are all speaking out against demonetisation, warning people that this move will ultimately harm the economy. Who is speaking in favour of the government, except some people who don’t have a choice but to — some film stars and some businessmen, who need to speak in favour of the government because they are scared to do otherwise. This is a scheme to ensure loot of common people’s money. The government has started a scheme where they will take money, in old notes, and then say that this is their revenue. They will claim that their revenue has increased. It’s a complete eyewash and dacoity.

Why do say that demonetisation is linked to elections?

The government isn’t releasing Rs 500 notes equally. We have asked the RBI to release the details of how many Rs 500 notes have been sent to which state. They haven’t done that yet. In West Bengal, the demand is far higher than other states. But here we have had almost no Rs 500 notes. Most of the ATM machines haven’t been recalibrated. But in BJP states, there is no such problem. In UP, they are not releasing Rs 500 notes because the BJP wants anger to build against the Samajwadi Party.

The Army has claimed that they had followed protocol regarding deployment in the state, what is your stand?

The Army is being used as a political tool. Whatever they are saying is misinformation and lies. It’s a concocted story. The Army never took permission from the state government. The home secretary has written to the Centre to withdraw the Army from the district. If the Army isn’t withdrawn, we will take legal action. We are being targeted because we have raised the issue of demonetisation.

So what do you think the Centre is attempting to do?

Curb protest. There is no money anywhere and the BJP can’t tolerate anyone’s protest. This has never happened before. The central government is an elected government but with limited mandate, we don’t interfere in their jurisdiction there. The state government has limited jurisdiction. But in this situation, the economy has no money, it’s impossible to give people wages. No one is getting money in hand. What will people do? Now the government is trying to scare you, so that you can’t go to the bank and take out money. This is yet another surgical strike.

The BJP is constantly attempting to weaken the federal structure of the state. They continue to speak directly to our secretaries, bypassing the chief minister. The Prime Minister holds video-conference meetings with the chief secretaries of the state. Why should he do that? There is a system in place and there is a reason for that. The Centre has no right to do so.

 

Written by Aniruddha Ghosal, The Indian Express, December 5, 2016

 

 

 

RBI’s disbursement of new notes discriminatory: Mamata Banerjee

Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Thursday alleged that the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) disbursement of new currency notes to States has been discriminatory.

With long queues outside banks and ATMs running dry on the first day of the month, Mamata Banerjee took to Twitter and wrote, “The salaried class people are not getting their own money from banks for their livelihood”, adding that if the organised sector was facing such serious crisis then one could easily imagine how grim the situation in the unorganised sector was.

Taking the country’s central bank head on, the Trinamool Congress supremo alleged that the RBI had “not given many state governments critically necessary funds despite announcements & promises”.

Rare Commodity

Terming the new Rs 500 note as a “rare commodity”, Mamata Banerjee alleged that the new notes have not been seen in most parts of Bengal.

“There is total discrimination in disbursement of cash between States,” she wrote on Twitter, adding that the RBI must release figures regarding how much currency was given to each state.

Demonetisation “draconian”

Ever since the Modi government’s announcement on demonetisation, Mamata Banerjee has been steadfast in her criticism of the move. The Trinamool Congress has demanded a complete rollback of the decision, terming it “draconian”.

In fact, Mamata Banerjee was the first Chief Minister to oppose the move. She has led protests against the move in Delhi, Lucknow and Patna.

 

নতুন নোট পাঠানো নিয়ে বৈষম্যমূলক আচরণ করছে রিজার্ভ ব্যাঙ্ক: মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়

বাংলার মুখ্যমন্ত্রী মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায় বৃহস্পতিবার অভিযোগ তোলেন, রাজ্যগুলোতে নতুন নোট পাঠানোর ক্ষেত্রে বৈষম্যমূলক আচরণ করছে রিজার্ভ ব্যাঙ্ক।

মাসের প্রথম দিন ব্যাঙ্ক ও এটিএম কাউন্টারগুলোর বাইরে সুদীর্ঘ লাইন হলেও ব্যাঙ্ক ও এটিএমগুলির ভাঁড়ার শুন্য। দিদি টুইটারে লেখেন “চাকুরীজীবি মানুষেরা নিজেদের সংসার চালানোর জন্য নিজেদের হকের বেতনের টাকাও পাচ্ছেন না।”

তিনি গভীর উদ্বেগের সঙ্গে জানান, যদি সংগঠিত ক্ষেত্রে এই পরিস্থিতির সম্মুখীন হতে হয়, তাহলে অসংগঠিত ক্ষেত্রে পরিস্থিতি কি ভয়ানক তা অনুমান করা যায়।

তৃণমূল নেত্রী বলেন, “অনেক ঘোষণা ও প্রতিশ্রুতি দেওয়া সত্ত্বেও রাজ্যগুলিকে প্রয়োজনীয় নোটের প্রায় কিছুই পাঠানো হয়নি।”

বিরল বস্তু

নতুন ৫০০ টাকার নোটকে “বিরল বস্তু” আখ্যা দিয়ে মাননীয়া মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায় বলেন, বাংলা সহ দেশের বেশির ভাগ জায়গাতেই এই নোট দেখা যাচ্ছে না।

তিনি টুইট করে দাবি জানান যে রিজার্ভ ব্যাঙ্কের এখনই জানিয়ে দেওয়া উচিত কোন রাজ্যকে তারা কত টাকা পাঠিয়েছেন।

 

 

Sudip Bandyopadhyay demands demonetisation discussion to be taken up along with voting | FULL TRANSCRIPT

The black money holders are very happy. They are not being touched. A ratio has been fixed up. 50-50. 50 is yours, 50 is with us. So this is the situation going on. We are actually interested t o see that black money holders are properly punished. Firm measures need to be taken. But, what is happening? common people are suffering a lot. They must be given relief.

I have told the other day also, Madam, we simply want discussion with voting. Time is running out and we need to make a beginning somewhere; this burning issue needs to be debated with all priority.  

In addition Madam, one issue, Rahul Gandhi’s mobile was hacked, telephone system too. That is to be also taken with priority. The manner in which the telephones of leaders are hacked and nasty statements are posted is alarming. The government must rise to the occasion and take care of it.

PM must withdraw his remarks before demonetisation debate can begin: Derek O’Brien | FULL TRANSCRIPT

Sir, the entire Opposition is one and has a same voice. Statements have been made by PM outside Parliament. I am fully supporting what the Leader of the Opposition said. We all want a debate. But the PM must withdraw his remarks first.

There is not a single member in this House who does not want a debate. We can start the debate in 2 mins if you want. But the issue is there were certain remarks made by the Prime Minister against the Opposition. We want him to withdraw the remarks.

Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra slams note ban

“Only an authoritarian government can calmly cause such misery to people,” said Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen on the government’s demonetisation move. Concurring with this thought Amit Mitra, Finance Minister of Bengal said no democracy with a money market has withdrawn 86 percent money from the market.

Dr Mitra said FMCG sales have fallen by 35-40 percent. About 70 percent of secondary steel plants in Bengal are not working after demonetisation. India is seeing recessionary tendency due to this move, he added. It will take six months for the government to remonetise the economy, Dr Mitra said. Economists have also agreed that gross domestic product (GDP) will decline by 100-300 bps due to demonetisation.

Joining the crusade against the currency ban, Dr Mitra said the government was not prepared to implement this scheme. Due to the cash clean-up, informal sector in all states is in deep trouble, he said. On deposits made in Jan Dhan account, he said for political purposes government had leaked that West Bengal ranked number one when on the contrary, the state is ranked number 10.

Talking about the Income Tax Amendments Bill announced by the government on Monday, the economist said the government has admitted its failure by introducing an amnesty scheme for the black marketeers.

Dr Mitra, who is also the Chairman of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Panel, said the indirect tax regime is the biggest fiscal reform in the country and it not a tax rate issue. Since the roll-out of the demonetisation scheme, there are serious concerns over GST rules. The scheme is a second whammy for the states, much bigger than GST process, Dr Mitra said.

Trinamool’s Derek O’Brien demands the presence of the Prime Minister in RS during the debate on demonetisation | FULL TRANSCRIPT

Sir, this is a serious issue. We want a debate in this House. We want the debate to continue. But the Prime Minister has said a lot of things outside the House, painting all political parties in a very poor light. He needs to come here and tender an apology. Let us carry on with the debate after that.

Opposition wants discussion on demonetisation to start in Lok Sabha, followed by voting. Why is the Government shying? | FULL TRANSCRIPT

Madam, today in the morning we wanted to say that we should make an obituary reference for the jawans who have lost their lives. It was not an attempt to hurt you through our walkout; if it has hurt you, we express our regret. But we still feel that the Government couldn’t supply you with positive information.

Madam, regarding the running of the House, it is absolutely correct that we have moved Adjournment Motion under Rule 56 and the treasury benches have want discussion under Rule 193. I am of the same opinion that there be discussion immediately. You can scrap Rule 56, you can also scrap Rule 193; you have every authority to find out the third way.

Why is the Government, in spite of a brute majority in the House with over 300 MPs, afraid for voting? That is to be clarified. We are for discussion. We will put our observation. We may shift from Rule 56 for the sake of the country, if necessary. They should also withdraw the demand for discussion under Rule 193 if necessary, but they should come to a position where you have your capacity, Madam.

You can endorse any rule, with voting. Discussion with voting is our only demand. You give consent to that and let the discussion start from tomorrow morning wholeheartedly. Let us exchange our ideas and views and come to a conclusion. We are committed against black money, we are committed to fight black money, we are committed to see that black money holders be sent to prison for life.

SS Roy asks RS Chairman to make obituary references to army jawans and people who died due to demonetisation | FULL TRANSCRIPT

Sir, I have given a Notice under Rule 267 so that this House makes obituary references. Ever since surgical strikes were carried out, our Army personnel have been martyred at the LOC. Even yesterday, our Army jawans lost their lives.

Sir, after demonetisation, 82 innocent lives were lost standing in queues outside banks. I demand that an obituary reference be made in the House. We must pay our respects to our jawans and our fellow citizens who have lost their lives.

We will continue our protests for the rights of the people: Mamata Banerjee in Patna

After her mega rally in Lucknow yesterday, Trinamool Congress Chairperson Mamata Banerjee addressed another rally today, this time at the Gardani Bagh ground in Patna. It was a protest against the Central Government’s decision to ban Rs 1000 and Rs 500 currency notes on November 8 and was attended by RJD leaders also.

She had arrived at the Bihar capital yesterday evening.

Mamata Banerjee began by recounting the immense hardships that people have been enduring since the decision on banning of Rs 1000 and Rs 500 currency notes was taken three weeks back, “After 60 years of independence, people’s independence has been taken away by force”.

She compared the current situation to that during the period of national Emergency in the 1970s: “The current situation is worse than Emergency, this is a financial emergency”.

She attacked the Central Government for ignoring the misery of the common people, saying, “It is the responsibility of the Government to work for the welfare of the people, not cause them suffering”, and reminding the Government that the “people will give them a befitting reply through ballot”.

She criticised the Centre’s propaganda on being able to flag black money hoarders through demonetisation, as the scheme was instead causing maximum problems for those who had nothing to do with black money: “Does the Government think that workers, labourers and housewives have black money?”

She instead demanded that the authorities target those members of political parties who deal in black money and use it for illegal transactions: “They should look at past records. They bought lands in the name of the party in September. They had advance information. Even on the day of the announcement of demonetisation they deposited huge amounts of money in their bank accounts”.

Mamata Banerjee attacked the Prime Minister on the issue of black money. She said, “Modi Ji goes on world tours. Look at his clothes and his lifestyle. He even brings crowds from outside. How much black money has been brought back from foreign countries?” Instead, he is pointing fingers at others, “He is accusing 86% of the people in India of possessing black money”.

The Trinamool Chairperson reminded the crowd of the Prime Minister and BJP leader’s failed promise: “The Prime Minister had promised to return Rs 15 lakh to everyone. Where is the money?”

Mamata Banerjee spelt out some of the problems that the people in general were facing: “It is the time for paying salaries but banks are running out of cash. How will things run? Lots of people from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh work in Bengal. They have all lost their livelihoods and are returning home”.

She pointed out the practical issues of having Rs 2,000 notes: “How will people do their daily shopping if banks give only Rs 2000 notes? Note printing presses do not have the capacity to print notes for normalising supply. It will take almost two years for it to happen”.

She extended her thanks to the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) for supporting the cause and inviting her to Patna: “I am grateful to RJD for extending their support to us”. She raised the slogan, “Ek taraf janta, ek taraf Modi/ Main janta ke saath rahungi” (On one side is the people, on the other, Modi/ I will be with the people”.

Mamata Banerjee attacked the Prime Minister’s lecturing people to go for plastic money (credit and debit cards) and online payments, as very few have access to those, and also cast her doubts as to his real intentions behind it: “The Pradhan Mantri is lecturing farmers to use Paytm. I want to ask him who is Alibaba? What is the deal with a mobile company and Paytm, Modi Ji?”

She also attacked the Government’s logic of asking people all over the country to withdraw money from banks and ATMs, saying, “Several villages in the country do not have banks. How will people survive there?

She also criticized the Centre’s asking people to get new currency notes from Big Bazaar outlets: “How many areas have Big Bazaar? How will areas without Big Bazaar outlets get cash?”

Another aspect Mamata Banerjee criticised is that of the Prime Minister himself announcing the policy: “Instead of the RBI Governor, the Prime Minister made this announcement. Technically, this is wrong”.

She also harped on the fact that several eminent economists have criticised this move: “Several eminent economists said demonetisation is a bad move. From Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen to World Bank economists to Manmohan Singh Ji have criticised the move”

She also came down heavily on the Government for inconsistencies on the new notes: “There are many inconsistencies in the new currency notes. How will people understand whether or not they are fake?”

She said, “The economy has slowed down. Industrial production has slowed down. They have snatched away the earnings of farmers, of workers, of labourers and of States, and are boasting of increase in earnings”.

She said, “They have sold off the country. There is no way we can support the BJP. We will continue our protests in the future for the rights of the people”.

বিগ বাজারের বিগ বস দেশের প্রধানমন্ত্রী হয়ে বসেছেনঃ মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায় 

লখনৌয়ের বিশাল জনসভার পর, আজ বুধবার পাটনায় কেন্দ্রীয় সরকারের নোট বাতিলের সিদ্ধান্ত প্রত্যাহারের দাবিতে জনসভা করেন তৃণমূল নেত্রী মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়।

মমতা বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায় বলেন, বিগ বাজারের বিগ বস এখন দেশের প্রধানমন্ত্রী হয়ে বসেছেন।  তাই সাধারণ মানুষের কষ্টের কথা না ভেবে তিনি এই তুঘলকি সিদ্ধান্ত নিয়েছেন।

 

তাঁর বক্তব্যের কিছু অংশঃ

সকল সমর্থকদের এখানে আসার জন্য ধন্যবাদ জানাই

আমি বিহারের সকলকে ধন্যবাদ জানাই তাদের সমর্থনের জন্য

স্বাধীনতার ৬০ বছর পরও মানুষের স্বাধীনতা জর করে ছিনিয়ে নেওয়া হচ্ছে

বর্তমান পরিস্থিতি জরুরী অবস্থার চেয়েও ভয়ংকর

সরকারের দায়িত্ব সাধারণ মানুষকে রক্ষা করা, সাধারণ মানুষ এখন তাদের কাজের জন্য দুর্ভোগের শিকার

মানুষ ওদের ভোট বক্সে উত্তর দেবে

ওরা মনে করে শ্রমিক, কর্মচারী, গৃহকর্ত্রী এদেরও কালো টাকা আছে?

নোট বাতিলের সিদ্ধান্তের পর ওরা কেন ওদের সাংসদ, বিধায়কদের অ্যাকাউন্টের হিসেব চাইছে? ওদের পুরনো রেকর্ডও দেখা উচিত

সেপ্টেম্বর মাসে ওরা পার্টির নামে জমি কিনেছে। আগে থেকেই ওদের সব কিছু জানা ছিল

নোট বাতিলের সিদ্ধান্ত ঘোষণার দিনও ওরা নিজেদের ব্যাঙ্ক অ্যাকাউন্টে অনেক টাকা জমা করেছে

মোদী জি বিদেশ সফর করছেন। ওনার পোশাক, জীবনযাত্রা দেখুন। নিজের সভায় বাইরে থেকে উনি লোক নিয়ে আসেন

বিদেশ থেকে কত কালো টাকা ফেরত এনেছেন?

ওনার মতে দেশের ৮৬% লোকের কাছেই কালো টাকা রয়েছে

গরীব মানুষের রক্ত জল করা পরিশ্রমের রোজগার উনি কেড়ে নিতে চাইছেন

প্রধানমন্ত্রী কথা দিয়েছিলেন সকলকে ১৫ লক্ষ টাকা ফিরিয়ে দেবেন। কোথায় সেই টাকা?

এখন মাসমাইনের সময় আর ব্যাঙ্ক ও এটিএমে কোন টাকা নেই। কিভাবে চলবে?

মানুষ কিভাবে তাদের জীবন ধারন করবে? কে তাদের ২০০০ টাকার নোট ভাঙিয়ে দেবে?

ওদের পরিমানমত নোট ছাপানোর ক্ষমতা নেই। এই অবস্থা স্বাভাবিক হয়ে অন্তত ২ বছর লাগবে

বিহার ও উত্তরপ্রদেশের অনেক লোক বাংলায় কাজ করেন। ওরা নিজেদের জীবনধারন করতে না পেরে বাড়ি ফিরে আসছেন

আর জে ডি আমাদের সমর্থন করেছে সেজন্য আমরা কৃতজ্ঞ

একদিকে জনগণ। আর একদিকে মোদী। আমি জনগণের সাথেই থাকব

প্রধানমন্ত্রী ভাষণ দিচ্ছেন পে টি এম ব্যবহার করার জন্য। আমি জানতে চাই আলিবাবা কে?

মোবাইল কোম্পানি আর পে টি এমের সঙ্গে লেনদেন কিসের মোদী জি?

দেশের অধিকাংশ গ্রামে ব্যাঙ্ক নেই। সেখানকার মানুষ কিভাবে বাঁচবেন?

কতগুলো জায়গায় বিগ বাজার আছে? কটা বিগ বাজারের দোকানে ক্যাশ পাওয়া যাচ্ছে?

ওরা কো-অপারেটিভ ব্যাঙ্ক বন্ধ করে দিয়েছে আর বিগ বাজারকে বিগ ব্যাঙ্কে পরিণত করেছে

আরবিআই গভর্নরের বদলে মোদী জি এই ঘোষণা করেছেন যেটা পদ্ধতিগতভাবে ভুল

নতুন নোটে অনেক অসংগতি রয়েছে। সাধারণ মানুষ কি করে বুঝবে কোনটা আসল আর কোনটা নকল?

ওরা দেশকে বিক্রি করে দিয়েছে। বিজেপিকে আর সমর্থন নয়

বহু অর্থনীতিবিদ এই নোট বাতিলের বিরোধিতা করেছেন

নোবেলজয়ী অমর্ত্য সেন  শুরু করে বিশ্ব ব্যাংকের অর্থিনীতিবিদ, অনেকেই নোটবন্দির বিরোধিতা করেছেন

সিনেমা জগতের কিছু লোক নোটবন্দিকে সমর্থন করেছেন। হয়তো ওদের ভয় দেখানো হয়েছে

দেশের অর্থনীতি ধ্বংস হয়ে গেছে। শিল্প উৎপাদন বন্ধ হয়ে গেছে

সাধারণ মানুষের জমানো টাকা, রাজ্যের টাকা কেড়ে ওরা বলছে ওদের আয় বেড়েছে

সাধারণ মানুষের জন্য আমাদের এই লড়াই চলবে

রাহা জনতা তো দেশ বাঁচায়েঙ্গে। রাহা দেশ তো মোদী যায়েঙ্গে

তানাশাহি নেহি চালেগা, যো হামসে টাকরায়েগা, চুর চুর হো যায়েগা। নোটবন্দি ওয়াপাস লো

Saugata Roy demands full-fledged discussion on Taxation Laws (Second Amendment) Bill, 2016 | FULL TRANSCRIPT

Madam, I want to refer to Rule 72, 74, 75 and Articles 117 and 274 of the Constitution of India. Madam, I am talking on the Taxation Laws (Second Amendment) Bill, 2016. Yesterday, at 2 pm, while there was din and turmoil in the House with Members protesting against demonetisation, the Finance Minister came surreptitiously and introduced the Bill. None of us had any idea. Normally what happens when a Bill is to be brought, is it is included in the List of Business. In yesterday’s List of Business, the Taxation Laws (Second Amendment) Bill was not there. If it was there, then we would have moved our opposition to its introduction under Rule 72(1). But, we are deprived of that basic opportunity of opposing the introduction of an anti-people Bill.

Then Madam, the next stage is under Rule 74, which says the Bill may be taken into consideration and then under Rule 75, which says there may be a discussion on the principles of the Bill. Now, the House, as you know Madam, has been in turmoil since November 16. Every day you are having to adjourn the House three to four times. Now this is a Bill which affects the Government’s efforts on black money, it’s misguided efforts on demonetisation, etc. and this is a follow-up of the Government’s decision to demonetise 500 and 1000 rupees notes. The House has been in total turmoil . All of us in the Opposition benches have vocally opposed the decision of the Government.

The Finance Minister is also proposing a Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan cess to give a special opportunity to black money holders. Now this is serious, Madam. So, this Bill should be discussed in all seriousness, a full-fledged deliberation must be held.


Another vital point has been mentioned by Mr Venugopal. Under Articles 117 and 274 of the Constitution, before bringing in the Bill, the President’s recommendation has to be obtained. The Minister must have obtained the President’s recommendation. We have put in amendments to the same. For the amendments to be fruitful, again, the President’s recommendation is needed under Articles 117 and 274.

Now all I want is a proper and structured discussion on the Government’s misguided efforts to curb black money through this Bill. It is necessary that the House be in perfect order before such a discussion can take place. And the House can be in perfect order after you have discussed the issue of demonetisation through an Adjournment Motion. Unless that happens, this Bill cannot be discussed.

The Government’s plan is to pass the Bill in the din, Madam; this should not happen. The future of this nation is at stake.