Lok SabhaRajya Sabha

February 7, 2019

Dinesh Trivedi speaks on Motion of the thanks on President’s address

Dinesh Trivedi speaks on Motion of the thanks on President’s address

FULL TRANSCRIPT

Aap ka mein bahut abhari hoon, mein Party ka abhari hoon, hamari netri Mamata Banerjee ka abhari hoon ke mujhe aapne is mahatwapurna mowke aur vishay par bolne diya. Sir, before I start, I will be speaking for 25 minutes, so I will request a little bit of patience from you all.

Sir, having said that mein mahamayi Rashtrapati ka abhari hoon ke unhone kasht liya ke dono sadano ke samne baat apni nahin rakkhi, kyonki yeh bahut purana tradition chala aa raha hai, British ka tradition hai jisko bolte hain “Monarch reads the speech, the speech of the Queen”. Aur hamare samvidhan ke Article 87 ke taher, baat hoti hai sarkar ki, magar para jata hai Rashtrapati ji ka. Mein yeh kyo keh raha hoon – mein isi liye kehe raha hoon ke hamare jo constructive aur truthful criticism hai, jo hamari baate hogi woh Rashtrapati ke prati nahin hain, sarkar ke prati hai. To yeh baat mein bohat hi spasht karna chahata hoon. Aur yeh bhi mein kehna chahata hoon ke Pradhan Mantri hamesha kehete hai ke humko kasauti de rakkho, sadan ko chunne do, humare jitne bhi buraiyan hai unko samne rakkho. To aaj usi spirit ke sehes me bolna chahata hoon…

Magar Kharge ji ne hamari mushkil badha bhi di aur aasan bhi kar di. Badha isi liye di ke jo unhone kaha tha rubaru woh sacchai hamare shamaks bhi thi, and I also wanted to talk about the same points. Aur hamare dwoovidha isiliye kam kar di ke Kharge ji ne jo kahaa, mein samajta hoon us taraf ki baat alag hai, magar is taraf ki jo log hai sabhi unke baat se sehemat hai. To mein us baat ko dourana nahin chahata hoon.

Sir, aisa hai ki sachhai hamesha sachhai hoti hai – na to Congress ki hoti hai, na to TMC ki hoti hai, woh aam janta ki hoti hai. I was very happy that the honourable President talked about 150th birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi. He talked about the Constitution Day, he talked about Guru Nanak ji, Ram Manohar Lohia… Mein samajta hoon Sir ki jab unhone kaha prior to 2014, honourable President ne jab kaha ki prior to 2014 general election, the country was passing through uncertainty. Mujhe aal bhi samaj nahin ata hai ki kounsi aise uncertainty thi. Kya sarkar nahin thi? Kya ye Parliament nahin tha, kya yeh samvidhan nahin tha? Han, abh sanvidhan par chot zaroor aa rahi hai. Magar yeh phrase hamare samaj ke bilkul bahar hai ki what was the uncertainty?

Mahamayi Rashtrapati ji ne New India ki baat ki. Us par mein lamba bolna chahunga thori der ke baad. Sir, yeh desh B.R. Ambedkar, Sardar Patel, Pandit Nehru, Sarvapalli Radhakrishnan, Subhas Chandra Bose, Rajendra Prasad, Govind Ballav, Govind Malviya – kitne hi mahapurush… Yeh desh in mahapurusho ka desh hai. Sarvapalli Radhakrishnan ne ek baat kaha thi, aur woh baat thi the Spirit of India. Unhone kaha tha committing suicide is a crime. But the bigger crime is getting away from the Spirit of India. Mujhe lagta hai ki hum woh Spirit of India se kuch alag hat rahen hai. Sir, mei yeh bhi kahna chahunga ki Kharge ji ne ek sher aur shaiyri se shurwad ki thi, aur yeh desh hamare bahut bare poet ka hai. Kaviguru Rabindranath Tagore ka yeh desh hai. Yeh desh hai hamari Rishi Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay ka – is desh mein bahut sare philosophy hai. Ek philosophy yeh bhi hai – waqt ki jab baat athi hai, ki maati gaye kumar se. Tu kya ro de mohe. Ek din aisa ayega, ki mei ro doongi tohe. Waqt, waqt ki baat hoti hai…

Piyush ji ne ek picture ki baat ki thi, si disha me mein – kyoki Kharge ji ne bahut kuch kahe diya hai, usko mein repeat nahin karna chahata hoon. Manikarnika nam ki ek picture abhi recently ayi. Ab us picture me kya tha jo aitihasik hai, ki Angrez zamane me Angrez kya karte the? Apko darate the, dhamkate the. Apke gharme ghus jate the aur kahte the ap humara sath do. Warna hum apka akraman karenge. Aj wohi dasha hay.
Jhansi ki Rani ki yaad ati hay, keuki e picture jo aitihasik hay, Jhansi ki Rani ki hay. Aur humne kuch dino pahle Jhansi ki rani kaun thi? Sadharan mahila thi. Jinko logo ne chuna tha, Jhansi ki rakhwale kijiye. Apne kya kiya? Apne akromon karte rahe, CBI lagayenge, upke pichhe ED lagayenge. Aap apka matha niche kar ligiye, humhare sath chale aiye. Barna hum akromon karenge, aur aap ne ae kiya. Bangal mey avi jo hua, chindino pahle e british government kartithe aam janta ke sath. Aur fir kya hua! Bangal mey aur ek Jhansi ki Rani hay. Jinka nam hay Mamata Banerjee. Mamata Banerjee ne kaha ki sar kata sakte hay, lekin sar jhuka nehi sakte. Yehi hay aj ki Jhansi ki Rani. Jo ek sadharan mahila hay, rani nehi hay. Unhone dikhaa diya ki aap jitna bhi hum par prohar kare hume kuchh farak nehi parta, keuki janta humhare sath hay.

Sir, apke suruyat huye thi acche din. Bahut dino ne humne ehi acche dino ki charcha suni nehi hay. Ae slogan pata nehin kaya gayeb ho gaye. Aj janta akrosh hay. Char chise hay jo apko chunab me jaha se ap aye the wahan vez degi. Aur e char chise kya hay? Ek to apne demonetization kiya. Kyaha gaya rat ko 8.15 me apne aylan kiya tha, jayse mughalbadsah eylan kiya karte the. Aj se apke currency 86% raad aur apke payse lene ke liye apko bhikhari bana diya. Apko line mey khara kar diya. Apko peyse se rasan laga diya. Aur bahut sare gorib mare gaye. Uske jo khun ka responsibility kaun lene bala hay?

Sir usi din mamta banerjee ne mujhe kaha, acche din ko baat chhoro. Inke buredin ap chalu ho gaye. Keuke aam janta, ko kya parisani hone bali thi! Wo mamta ji ko bahut achchhi tara pata hay.

Sir, dusri baat jo apko kha jaye gi, wo unemployment. Agriculture crisis and ruining the economy of this country. Yaadi apko janna hay na, kis prokar sarkar chalani hay, kis prokar jojonay chalani hay, to ap bangle ki screen dekhiye. Chahe wo kanyasree ho, rupasree ho, yubasree ho, shikshasree ho, krishaksree ho, aur hamara jo sabse bara accha jo health scheme hay swastha saathi, jo humhare bangle mey banaya giya hay, wo aj kohibhi ja ke muft elach kara sakte hay.

Sir, Hum uski bat age nehi kahunga aur apki baat age rakhte huyen e kahunga ke jo apne unemployment ki baat kahin, unemployment aj sar par chara huya hai. Sir, today unemployment rate jo 40 saal se jaada. It is much more for 4 decades to put together 6.1% unemployment rate. World Employment and Social Outlook – Trends, wo batata hay aap ko ki 77 of the Indian workers would be vulnerable and 18.9 million people are unemployed by this year.

This year 2019.The micro, small scale MSME and traders have registered a huge decline. According to CMIA survey 3.5 million jobs were lost due to demonetisation. The impact of the labour force was even much more significant. While the job losses could have been at least 3.5 million, the reduction in the labour force was to the tune of 15 million.
Sir, main ab demonetisation mein ayunga, sansed mein kahunga kyuki Rashtrapatiji ne unka ullekh kiya hai.

One of the aim of demonetisation was to fight fake currency. Problem according to RBI, ye main RBI ka data keh raha hu. 522.783 pieces of currency, matlab 5 lakh 22 thousand se zyada currency fake note jo pahle thae usse zyada ho gya. RBI also highlighted in his annual report of 2017-18 the value of bank notes circulations increased by 37.77 percent.Sir, main iske detail mein jana nehi chahta hu yehi kehna chahta hu ki aap ka jo hai wo pura ka pura jo demonetisation pura fail ho gaya hai.
Sir, more than 25 million people a number greater than Australia’s population have applied for about 90 thousand positions in the railway. Uska matlab kya dikhata hai? Aap GDP ki jitni bhi fake aakre kijiye apka unemployment charam seema pe pouich chuka hai.25 thousand application for 90 thousand jobs.Sir, char hazar graduates hai abhi, 14 sweeper ke jobs ke liye apply kiya hai 4hazar graduates hai.

Sir, apka economic survey jo batata hai ki In the last four years the level of real agriculture GDP and real agriculture revenue has remained constant, matlab 1.9. ap jo double baat kar rahe hai ki apki income double hogi, Swaminathan report ko apne lagu nhi kiya hai. Mamata Banerjee ne triple income already hamare krishi ki bangal mein kar di hai. wo ayegi delhi tab pata chalega ki asli kishan ka dekh rekh kaun kar raha hai.

Sir, main apko yeh kahunga- Today the democracy is in danger, institutions of democracy has been compromised. Parliament ko le lijiye Sir. Why did you bulldozed all all the legislations?yaha gatividhi hoti hai. Rail se admi kyu jata hai?hum sabko pasand bilkul nehi hai hai rail pe jakar gatirodh kare. Ye constitution jo hamare liye jeeta hai, sabkuch hai. Iss constitution ko jab ap amend karte hai 7 tarikh ki raat ko januaryapki cabinet ki meeting hoti hai 10 percent arakshan dene ke liye .Doosre subhe 8 tarikh ko Question Hour ke turant baad Constitution Amendment Bill hamare samne rakha jata hai, yeh kaunsi insaafi hai aur yeh kahaka loktantra hai? Apne iss ko mandir mana, hum issko mandur mante hai. Ap jab aaye toh matha naman kiya magar haqueqat kya hai ki apne hume mauka toh nehi diya magar aam janta ko bhi mauka nehi diya toh apne parliament bill kohi bhang kardiya.

Judiciary Sir, Democracy is in danger- yeh hum nahi keh rahe hai. 12 January 2018, 4 senior most judges keh rahe hai the way the courts are being run if it is run like this Democracy would be in danger. aur ye bhi keh rahe hai during the press conference- Justice Gogoi told journalists that their move is partly because of the death of the Justice Loya, this has been reported.

Sir, kya hota hai raat ko 1.30 baje on Wednesday midnight 25th October Delhi Police kya karti hai? Delhi Police jakar to save the Delhi police cordoned off the Lodhi road building escorted by the Delhi Police. Ap adhi raat raat ko jakar pura apka CBI ka complex Delhi Police jakar gher leti haI aur kyu gher leti hai? CBI ka number one usko aap hatane jate hai aur it is reported ap unko kyu hatana chahte hai. apki aisi koi constitutional validity nehi hai jiske tehet ap usko hata sakte hai.
Magar jo report me aa raha hai ki shayad wo Rafale deal ki bare me kuch kadi si kadi karvai karna chahte the lekin adhi raat me aapne usko hata diya. Ye kaha ki democracy hai? Ye zara hame baataiye. Media par aapko jo dabao hai wo sab janta hai. Aur kya hota hai? CBI officer on Chanda Kochar case transfer a day after filing FIR. Wo transfer kue hota hai? Kuiki hamare dost jo Mr. Arun Jaitly 22 tarikh ko tweet karte hai. Aur kaihte hai ki a galat kiya. Aap isko itni jaldi janch mat kijiye. Professional investigation targets the guilty and protects the innocent. It secures conviction and further public interest. One of the reasons why our conviction rates are poor is adventurism and megalomania overtakes our investigators and professionalism takes a back seat. Yehi Bangal me hua ki professionalism took a back seat. Aur aapka maksad bahut hi galat tha.

Sir, Jo bhi aapke samne aata hai achhe ankre rakhne chahta hai, sabko aap ghar bhej dete hai, aap kaihte hai my way or no way or high way. Raghuram Rajan ki bat ki, Urjit Patel ki baat ki, Arvind Subhraminium, Arvind Panagariya sabki baat thi. Toh mai usko report karna nehi chahta hu.

Sir, aap hamesha Sree Ramchandra jee ki baat karta hai. Mahabharat, Ramayan, Ramchandra jee aap ek drishyo kijiye ki kekei Raja Dasrath. Ke bhai aapne jo wada kiya hai wo wada ka palan kijiye. Ek wada yeh hai ke aap Ramchandra jee ko banbas kijiye aur Bharat ko aap gadda me bichayye. Toh unhone kya kaha? “Ragu ko ri sada chali aaye pran jaye par bachan na jaye.” Magar aapne bachanto diya 15 lakh ka, wo bachan ka kya hua? Toh Ramchandra jee ki baat karne se baat banti nehi hai. Aapke liye Ramchandra jee sirf ayodha me honge. Hamare liye Ramchandra jee kankad me hai. Haar hawa ki jhoke mei hai. Haar pani ki boond me hai. Mei toh samajhti hu haar byakti ki andar me hai.

Sir, aap mei sidha ayunga kya aap naya Bharat ki baat karte hai na aur mei aapko baat ka khatam karunga. Your concept about new India is destroying democracy. Your new India is about destroying institutions. Your new India is about destroying the Constitution of India. Your new India is about sabotaging new generation. Your new India is about creating fear. Your new India is about finishing federal structure. Your new India is about my way or no way. Your new India is about me and not us. This is your concept of new India. Your new India is about unemployment. Your new India is about agriculture crises. Your new India is the largest NPAs. Your new India is about destroying RBI to CBI, institutions to Constitution. Your new India is about destroying, not recognising the norms of Parliament.

Sir, your new India is about bulldozing the bills in parliament without discussion. Your new India is about farji deta. Your new India is about should of patriotism. Your new India is not to follow Rajdharam. Your new India is to divide and miss route. Your new India is to destroy the secular all you of Vivekananda, Gandhiji, Patel, Ambedkar, Netaji, Moulana Azad, Kabir, Tulsi Das. Your new India is against the ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam. Your new India means destroying our Ganga Jamuna Kaijib. Jahan Dalit bhi hain, Mera bhi hai, Md. Rafi bhi hai aur Lata Mangeshkar bhi hai. Your new India means destroying the youth. Your new India means lowest farmers income 1.9%. Your new India means about farmers suicide. Your new India means 77% of Indian workers out of the workforce. Your new India means MSME and all down. Your new India means not achieving the object of demonetisation. Your new India is biggest jumla of 2019 election. Your jumla for 2014 was achhedin. Please understand. You can fool all people sometimes, some people all the time, but not all people all times. Aapki expiry date khatam hue. Aapki baat khatam hue. Log aap se naraz hai. Aur hamare liye sarfarosi ki tamanna aab hamare dil me hai, dekhna hai jor kitna baju a katil me hai. 2019 BJP finish!