Sudip Bandyopadhyay suggests including Belur-Dakkhineshwar in religious tourism circuit

Hon’ble Minister has placed names of 13 pilgrimage sites identified for development and beautification under your scheme. Why have you not inducted under this scheme Dakkhineshwar and Belur Math? Belur is Swami Vivekananda’s dream; Ramakrishna Paramhansa Dev’s name is associated with Dakkhineshwar.

Even our Prime Minister Hon’ble  Modi Ji before election went to take blessings from Belur Math. After election he went to visit the present President Swami Atmasthananda Ji Maharaj who is very ill and is admitted at Golpark Ramakrishna Mission Hospital.

My question is that whether the list you have declared can induct Belur Math and Ramakrishna Mission? There is Nimtala Ghat on the river Ganges side where Kabiguru Rabindranath Tagore was cremated; Ramakrishna Paramhansa Dev and Swami Vivekananda were cremated at Ratan Babu Ghat. These are all on the same area. I think that these spots can be very positive spiritual places for the tourists.

I am surprised to see that in 2013-2014 & 2014-15 you have not allotted a single rupee for the state of West Bengal. It is no more a communist state. Religious and spiritual places are there in Bengal. Why can’t the government consider further allocation for the two states in a bigger way?

Thank you.

Full solidarity with Tamil Nadu, but don’t deprive Bengal: Trinamool

Leaders of Trinamool Congress today expressed solidarity with the people of Tamil Nadu while questioning the Central Government why Bengal has been deprived of funds for flood and drought relief.

“Our thoughts and prayers are with the people of Tamil Nadu and Andhra. Give aid to Tamil Nadu and Andhra. They deserve your attention. We are with them. But why is Bengal being deprived,” asked Derek O’Brien, leader of the party in Rajya Sabha.

His sentiments were echoed by Sudip Banerjee, leader of the party in Lok Sabha. “I wanted to know categorically that what is the system of allotment of money, the central team goes and comes back, but the amount that is decided is not fixed in consultation with the Chief Ministers of the states or their representatives, it is suo motu. They take the decision absolutely on their own,” he said.

West Bengal government had soughts funds to the tune of Rs 6,000 crore due to the flood and Rs 4,000 crore due to drought. WB CM has written several letters to the Prime Minister in this regard.

Sukhendu Sekhar Roy wanted the Home Minister to clarify if the Rs 300 crore fund released by SDRF was an interim relief.

Derek O’Brien insisted that the Centre give full attention to Tamil Nadu and Andhra but not deprive Bengal in the process.

 

Click here for full transcript of Sudip Bandyopadhyay’s speech

Click here for full transcript of Derek O’Brien’s speech

Sudip Bandyopadhyay slams the Centre over funds for flood/drought relief in Bengal

Full Transcript

I had mentioned yesterday that West Bengal is affected both by floods and drought. Accordingly, Venkaiah Naidu ji intimated me that Rs 387 crore has been released from SDRF. The state’s demand was Rs 6,000 crore due to the flood and Rs 4,000 crore due to drought.

I wanted to know categorically that what is the system of allotment of money, the central team goes and comes back, but the amount that is decided is not fixed in consultation with the Chief Ministers of the states or their representatives, it is suo motu. They take the decision absolutely on their own.

Madam, in Planning Commission it was the system that the compensation amount was decided in the presence of the Chief Minister and the finance minister. But this is one-sided, unilateral decision. So, we strongly protest against this decision and we feel that it is difficult for those in West Bengal to survive and as a mark of protest, we are walking out against the government’s stand.

What I am saying is that the eastern zone is economically deprived. West Bengal particularly is most exploited and deprived. The eastern states are the worst sufferers of regional imbalances and the situation still persists.

My humble submission is take some special care of the eastern region which includes Bengal, Odisha, Assam, Bihar and Jharkhand. I think they should be given some priority. The eastern region should be allowed to be free as they are the worst sufferers of regional imbalances.

Sudip Banerjee speaks in Lok Sabha regarding flood situation in the country

The flood, as well as drought, situation have affected our country. Huge areas are under flood and half of India is drought affected. 302 out of 614 districts are reeling under drought, highest since 2009. And 40% of India’s different areas are now affected with flood. Flood has very badly affected Tamil Nadu and west Bengal also.

Madam, I raised this issue during the all party meeting convened by you that on 25th November. The State Government had asked for a relief of Rs 6000 crore. How much money has been allotted by the center to fight back this situation? On the very subject very promptly Venkaiah Naidu Ji assured me that he will send me the reply.

Accordingly, he has sent me a reply:

“Dear Sudip Da, the information is Bengal got the entire amount. SDRF Rs 367 crore has been released for this year. Further details will be available tomorrow afternoon. I will possibly let you know the further information.”

But when the State Government asked for Rs 6000 crore, how SDRF released only 367 crore? I want to know what is the system of assessment? How does the Central team assess the situation, gravity of the situation? They go together with the state government for assessment of the situation. But when they take the decision they take it of their own which we broadly disown.

Madam, Tamil Nadu no doubt is worse affected. Let them get more money. We have full support. What I hard yesterday their demand was much higher than what has been sanctioned. This is the reason why we are telling that the situation is becoming very difficult to be tackled by state’s own monitory fund.

Madam, the Central Government is not releasing the money on time and State Government is not capable to tackle the situation with their own sources. Moreover, funds for various central schemes have been stopped. Then again after July there is no rain in the country except a few places. So, drought is equally affecting the country.

West Bengal is a sufferer of both flood and drought. Four districts, particularly Bardhaman, Bankura, Purulia & West Medinipur, are affected with flood. Unprecedented rainfall one side, and drought on the other side is actually a serious condition.

We propose that farmers and flood affected people be provided with drinking water, food, alternative seeds for Sech Prakalpa. On the other side, DVC is not giving water. Tenughat of West Bengal project has no water. How can the situation be overcome? So I would request the Central Government to give necessary instruction to release DVC water for the purpose in consultation for the State Government at the earliest possible time.

Madam due to flood and drought very poor people, specially farmers, lose their income and assets and they face a distress. They become much poorer. The government has a huge stock of food grains with Food Corporation of India. I would also suggest that FCI can supply more amount of food grains to the flood affected areas or to the drought affected areas.

Madam, in deficit monsoon, death of farmers is very much alarming. Central assistance is also being reduced for ICDS projects on the earlier stage, the Central Government used to give the larger portion of the funds to run the ICDS projects but now it has been reversed wherein the state will have to bear the maximum portion and the Centre will pay the minimum portion; it is another burden on the shoulder of the state government.

We tell here again and again that West Bengal government has to repay a loan and debt of Rs 2,20,000 crore. And for that Rs 28,000 crore is taken away by the central government annually. So we have categorically stated that the present government is in a precarious condition.  The state government which ruled for 34 years had taken a loan, and the fresh government which has taken over has to bear the burden.

The Centre can take some positive steps through the centrally aided projects during such situations like this. In the MGNREGS, we can include additional days of work. Diesel subsidy scheme can be started for farmers of the affected areas. Enhancement of ceiling on seed subsidy, interventions for saving horticulture crops, implementation of additional fodder development programs, these are all central schemes and I want to know how they are rising to the occasion. What is the progress of allocation of Rashtriya Krishi Yojana? I want to know about the availability of seeds and other inputs for the Kharif month of 2015, crisis management plan for drought in the year 2015.

These sort of crises should be handled with a certain amount of farsightedness and imagination which requires advance planning. Global Warming is equally becoming a part of these weather changes. The whole world is becoming conscious. In Paris there was a huge convention where these issues have been consulted and discussed.

Regarding the functioning of the SDRF, State Disaster Response Fund, there is a system where the central government gives some money to the state government in advance. But if the flood or drought occurs on a large scale then the government has to spend it primarily. The state government of West Bengal has already spent more than Rs 1000 crore in spite of the huge financial crisis. They have asked for Rs 6000 crore but only Rs 367 crores has been released and the state has not received it. And I came to know about this release order from Venkaiah Naidu ji.

My submission is that while Tamil Nadu should be treated with priority, the government of India must rise to the occasion regarding West Bengal’s flood and drought situation with all sorts of assistance. Centre should discuss with the Chief Ministers of the states in a broad way and a central team should visit and assess the situation. The Chief Ministers are the people’s representative and when they are asking for some financial assistance it should be taken with all priority.

So, Madam, this discussion was very much important for I think those states which are affected by drought and flood.

Thank you.

Trinamool demands flood relief from Centre in Parliament

During a discussion regarding flood situation in the country, leader of the party in Lok Sabha, Sudip Bandyopadhyay today demanded that the Centre release funds for flood relief in Bengal.

“Despite huge financial crisis, West Bengal Government has already spent Rs 1000 crore for flood relief. Centre must deal with flood and drought in Bengal in equal priority as flood in Tamil Nadu,” he said.

“The new government in Bengal has a huge burden of debt on its shoulders. Some positive steps must be taken by Central Government to help Bengal,” he added.

The Kolkata North MP said that since the Centre does not release funds on time, it becomes difficult for the State to manage. “When we asked for Rs 6000 crore how did SDRF sanction only Rs 387 crore. What is the system of assessment?” he demanded to know.

People from low income groups become poorer at time of flood and government must take care of their food and living, Sudip Bandyopadhyay suggested.

 

Derek’s suggestions for disaster management in RS

In the Rajya Sabha, during a similar discussion, leader of the party Derek O’Brien put forth few suggestions for better disaster relief in future.

Derek suggested that the reporting process of NDRF must be simplified and budgetary allocations of NDRF increased.

“NDRF operates out of only 4000 sq ft office space. CAG report says NDMA is ill-prepared to handle a disaster,” Derek said.

He also maintained that while he has no problem with Tamil Nadu getting its share of funds for flood relief, the concerns of West Bengal must also be taken into account.

Citing the letter written by WB CM to the Prime Minister in August, Derek said, “Please do not penalise the states which have taken preemptive measures to reduce loss of lives.”

“There are very few states which are both prone to drought as well as cyclone. Bengal is one of those. I hope govt will surely look into the issue of Bengal, like they are doing in Chennai,” the MP added.

 

Click here for the full transcript of Sudip Bandyopadhyay’s speech in LS

Click here for the full transcript of Derek O’Brien’s speech in RS

CPM and BJP playing a got-up game to stall Parliament: Sudip Bandyopadhyay

Leader of Trinamool in Lok Sabha, Sudip Bandyopadhyay today alleged that the CPM and BJP are playing a got-up match in the Lok Sabha to stall the debate on intolerance.

“I want to ask the CPM and BJP if this is a got-up match. It appears to me that the CPM and BJP have decided they will not allow the intolerance debate to take place,” he said.

 

Adjournment Motion

Earlier today, he moved an adjournment motion in Lok Sabha to discuss the very urgent issue of escalating price rise.

“The prices of essential commodities is skyrocketing. Hungry people are fighting with hunger,” Sudip Bandyopadhyay said on the flood of the House.

He also suggested that the government must bring 15 essential commodities under public distribution system, which will largely benefit poor people.

Tourist inflow

During the Question Hour, Sudip Bandyopadhyay suggested to the Union Tourism Minister that the Centre should consider launching a tiger safari in Sunderbans (on the lines of South African safari) to boost the footfall of foreign tourists to the country.

The Kolkata North MP also suggested that Darjeeling – which is the Queen of Hills – should be brought on the World Tourism Map to boost tourist inflow to India.

The Union Minister promised that the proposals will be considered by his Ministry.

Sudip Bandyopadhyay speaks in Lok Sabha on the commemoration of 125th birth anniversary of Dr BR Ambedkar

The subject of the day was initiated by the Hon’ble Speaker in a very dignified manner: The Constitution Day and Dr Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar, who was the Father of the Constitution making Committee.

Our Constitution, Sir, which was adopted on 26th November, 1949, was a combination of hard work, foresightedness of great minds of the time like Pt Jawaharlal Nehru, Sardar Patel, Shri A K Ayer, Sri B N Rao, Janab Sayed Mohd Sadullah, Sri N Madhabrao Rao, Sri D P Khaitan, Dr Rajendra Prashad and Sri T N Gopalaswami.

Sir, however it is accepted and acknowledged by peers that Dr Ambedkar, as Chairman of the Drafting Committee had contributed the most in shaping the final Constitution of India.

In the words of Dr Rajendra Prasad, the President of the Constituent Assembly and later the first President of India, “I have carefully watched the day-to-day activities of the presidential seat. Therefore I appreciate more than others, with how much dedication and vitality, this task has been carried out by the Drafting Committee and by its Chairman Dr Ambedkar in particular. We never did a better thing than having Dr. Ambedkar on the Drafting Committee and selecting him as its Chairman.”

Sir, I would better mention here, that in the council which was set up, Dr Ambedkar represented West Bengal. He was born in Madhya Pradesh. He was ultimately in the Constituent Assembly. Along with him, there were Sarat Chandra Bose, father of Dr Sugata Bose, who is present over here, belonging to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose’s family, Mr Gurung, Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, Prafulla Chandra Sen, our former Chief Minister, Prafulla Chadra Ghosh, our former Chief Minister.

Babasaheb Ambedkar was elected from West Bengal as Mahatma Gandhiji wanted him to be inducted in the Committee but Maharashtra or Madhya Pradesh did not recommend him.

Among the diverse facets and talents of Dr Ambedkar, the one that stands out extremely tall is his unequivocal championing of social equality for all Indian citizens, especially the Dalit community. He was of the opinion, before Independence, that Dalits should be treated distinctly from the Hindus.

Dr Ambedkar’s stamp is reflected in some provisions of Part 3 and many parts of Part 4 dealing with the Constitutional mandates to ameliorate the condition of the schedule castes and scheduled tribes and other backward classes. Article 3 deals with the protection of the minorities. It is to be kept in mind that Article 15 prohibits untouchability. Sadly, we have not yet been able to eradicate the menace of the society till date. Probably, it will be a befitting tribute to Dr Ambedkar if we pledge to eradicate this discriminatory attitude as it will also help our nation to progress both socially and economically.

Dr Ambedkar was, Sir, was totally in favour of the Parliamentary form of the Government. We are the firm believers of the Parliamentary democratic system. Since the inception of the Government of India Act, 1935, he firmly believed that the Parliamentary system of the Government can only usher in an egalitarian society through the application of the principle of social democracy. He was also a strong advocate of the federal structure of Union and the States. He believed that due to diversity in region, culture, language, religion and food habits, it is best that States should enact its own variation based on the Constitution. Accordingly, Article I of the Constitution states India as Union of States.

Sir, there were so many national leaders at that time when the Constitution was set up. But amongst the leaders Dr Ambedkar was the most educated. He was MA, MSc, PhD, DSc, Bar at Law, with vast experience as educationist, parliamentarian and administrator. And Sir, after Independence, Jawaharlal Nehru inducted him as the Law and Judicial Minister.

Sir, how do we remember Dr B R Ambedkar? Dr B R Ambedkar could not take part in the freedom struggle of the country. But, he is no doubt, the hero who built an independent India’s Constitution. Babashaheb Ambedkar was an Indian nationalist, jurist, Dalit political leader, activist, philosopher, thinker, anthropologist, historian, orator, prolific writer, economist, scholar, editor, revolutionary and the revivalist of Buddhism in India.

Sir, he spent his whole life for the betterment of the poor, exploited and the troubled classes. We here have to reaffirm our commitments to the holy Constitution, Sir.

Sir, this is a country where we sing the song:

“Nana Bhasa Nana Mat, Nana Paridhan

Bibidher majhe dekho milon mahan”

There are many languages, many opinions, many dresses. In spite of that we are the firm believers of unity in diversity. This is the ethos and we are also the firm believers of the secularism, communal harmony and the unity of the country.

We think that nobody should oppose the term secular’. Being the Home Minister of the country, Rajnath Singh ji should not criticise the existing Constitution as it stands now.

Sir we sing “Hindu, Bouddha, Sikh, Jain, Parsi, Musalman, Christian”. This is the character, ethos of the country. Sir, this is the country where the great poet Iqbal sang “Sare Jahan Se Accha, Hindstan Hamara”. We should not forget this.

Sir, Indian Constitution reflects these principles.

Sir, we salute and want to remain committed towards this Constitution. We will remain dedicated to protect this Constitution. We will keep it upheld with the last drop of our blood. I saw the Twitter message today issued by the Prime Minister. I believe it is the correct feeling which should have been reflected on the floor of the House and that could been the actual line of the first speaker of the Government side.

Sir, attempts have been made to burn the Constitution in different programmes. We represent Bengal. There is a place in Bengal named Naxalbari in Darjeeling district where Maoist movement started. This party, in a public meeting at Shahid Minar in Kolkata publicly burnt the Constitution. Many political parties, few in the north-eastern regions, in the name of their movements, disobeyed and lit fire to the Constitution. In the name of the Khalistan movement, they disobeyed the Indian Constitution. It was burnt. But the efforts of these forces have never been successful. They could not reach their target.

Sir, there may be differences with the present Constitution. I do not differ with that. But, there are scopes for that amendment. One hundred amendments have been made to the Constitution till today. The opportunities are open, all scopes are there.

Sir, now I want to give some stress on federalism and federal structure of Government about which you were also a little vocal today, at the beginning.

Article one of the constitution says India is a union of states. But in reality there are attempts of harming the federal structure of the country. How will the Centre be strengthened if states become weak?

Sir a Government comes to power after 34 years a loan burden of Rs 2,36000 crore. And if this loan burden is to be carried by the new government how can they function? This is the case with my State. Present Chief Minister is carrying a burden of Rs 2,36000 crorse on her shoulder. In spite of that this state government is functioning.

I do not know that what constitution says here. If any state is asks for special assistance, the normal reply is that if such assistance is given to one state, the entire country will claim them. But such assistance is sometimes given. Jammu & Kashmir, Bihar, Tamil Nadu and even Punjab received special assistance. Let them get more assistance. We have no objection to that. But Bengal should not be neglected and deprived, Sir.

Dr Ambedkar was a strong advocate of the federal structure based on the principle of a strong centre and independent states.

Now I will come to the issue of tolerance. This issue was raised by Hon’ble President  of India himself. He expressed his views on intolerance when he was visiting his village during Durga Puja.

Few incidents of intolerance have happened. India is a country of tolerance. And whole world has a respect for us, for that season. But few incidents are sending negative messages to the world.

Sir, every citizen, every religion certainly have their own right to observe their customs. They can practice them in their own ways and style. But now a days we are witnessing a sense of intolerance in many cases. Responsibility in such instances automatically comes on the shoulder of the government running the country.

We should make a firm commitment that such incidents will not be tolerated in the country. It will be the best respect shown to be Hon’rble Dr B. R. Ambedkar if we are firmly united while protesting against these issues.  And in this case Hon’ble Prime Minister will have to rise to the occasion.

When such incidents happen he must criticise them in the country, not when he is travelling abroad. If he tackles issues remaining present on the floor of the House it will give a very positive signal to the nation and to all of us. I would appeal to him to consider this issue.

Sir, I am also concerned that intolerance also gives the birth of terrorism. It should be a matter of great concern to us that Shahrukh Khan, Aamir Khan, AR Rahman, Mithun Chakrabarty are feeling uneasy in our own country. We need to find out why they are saying so. They are all responsible and respectful artists of the country. Why they are facing this?

India showed the world how freedom struggle can be fought without. We saw how India fought against the British rulers with patience, with tolerance. Intolerance must be condemned from every corner.

Sir, this is the country of Sri Sri Ramakrishna Paramhansa Deb and Swami Vivekananda. This is the country where why we should not show intolerance. Sri Sri Ramakrishna Paramhansa said ‘Joto Mot, Toto Poth’ (As Many Opinions, That Many Ways).

Sir, I would say in conclusion that Dr Ambedkar deserves to be called the chief architect of the Indian Constitution. We must be united and ensure that Parliamentary democratic system be protected. The contribution of Dr Ambedkar in Indian democracy must not to be forgotten. His name will be written in golden letters in the history of India as a creator of social justice. We salute Gandhiji, Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, Sardar Ballav Vai Patel and Dr. B. R. Ambedkar.

Sir, we should not hesitate to raise our voice in the House. We will request Hon’ble Prime Minister to look into these issues with top most priority. We commend the decision to celebrate the 125th birth anniversary of Dr Ambedkar. We are committed to protect this constitution with the last drop of our blood.

Thank you, Sir.

Sudip Bandyopadhyay bats for tolerance in Lok Sabha

Speaking in Lok Sabha during a special sitting to commemorate the 125th birth anniversary of Dr BR Ambedkar, the leader of the party in Lok Sabha, Sudip Bandyopadhyay today asked the Prime Minister to rise to the occasion and act against the incidents of intolerance in the country.

“Every citizen have the right to practice their own religion. Few incidents are sending out a negative image of the country,” he said.

The Kolkata Uttar MP added, “People like Shahrukh Khan, Aamir Khan, A R Rahman, Mithun Chakraborty are feeling unsafe in their own country. We must find the cause.”

“This is the country of Sri Sri Ramakrishna Paramhansa Deb and Swami Vivekananda. We must show tolerance. Sri Sri Ramakrishna Paramhansa said ‘Joto Mot, Toto Poth’ (As Many Opinions, That Many Ways). We must respect this spirit,” said Sudip Banerjee.

He also showered praises on Dr BR Ambedkar, the chief architect of our Constitution who was elected to the Constituent Assembly from Bengal. He said Ambedkar was a revivor of Buddhism in India and a social engineer.

We should unequivocally lodge our protests from the Parliament against the incidents of intolerance, Sudip Bandyopadhyay advised the Prime Minister while concluding his speech.

 

Full transcript of his speech here

Trinamool wants Parliament to function: Sudip Bandopadhyay

Ahead of the Winter Session this week, Trinamool Congress on Saturday said it does not favour disrupting of Parliament proceedings and will raise issues of intolerance, communal harmony and strengthening of federal structure in the House.

“The strategy of our party is yet to be decided. It will be decided after discussions with our party chief Mamata Banerjee. But yes, we want the Parliament to function properly. We don’t want any disruption of the house,” TMC Parliamentary Party leader in Lok Sabha Sudip Bandopadhyay said.

“If Parliament functions smoothly, we will be able to raise the burning issues of the country such as price rise, intolerance, threat to secularism and others. We can make the government answerable for these issues,” he said.

Sudip Bandopadhyay said, “The issue of intolerance and threat to communal harmony will top our agenda.”

“Never before has India gone through such an intolerant atmosphere. We want to raise this issue of intolerance in the Parliament. We have always spoken in favour of strengthening communal harmony of our country. In the present situation the communal harmony too is under threat,” he added.

The MP also lashed out at the Centre for interfering in the federal structure of the country.

“We have always spoken in favour of strengthening the federal structure and for more powers to the states. But under the present regime at the centre, the Prime Minister is calling up chief secretaries of the state bypassing the chief ministers.

“Is this the way you protect the federal structure, which is the basis of our country? We all need to strengthen the federal structure,” he added.

Sudip Bandyopadhyay speaks in Lok Sabha on Gurdaspur terror attack

The issue has already been discussed. It is a good precedent and I think let this issue be taken up with all priority so that we can initiate a discussion at the earliest possible time.

There is no doubt that it is a national issue. There are other issues also, which are to be taken care of by the Government, whether it is the corruption issue, the land issue or the black money issue.

Whatever issues they may be, we want to discuss all these issues on the floor of the House, and I think you should begin it from somewhere.

This issue of terrorism must be dealt with very firmly by the Government. The Hon’ble Home Minister must present his statement on the floor of the House at the earliest.

Thank you.