earthquake

Our prayers are with the people of Nepal: Trinamool in Parliament

Trinamool Congress today expressed grief and sorrow at the immense loss of life and property in Nepal and parts of India due to the earthquake on 25 April, 2015.

During a discussion in both Houses of the Parliament, Derek O’Brien and Saugata Roy extended solidarity with the people of Nepal in Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha respectively.

“The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) was dissolved. Out of a board of 12 odd members, only three members have been appointed so far. My humble suggestion to the government is not to keep those seats vacant,” Derek O’Brien said.

He added that the formula to handle such situations was PIC – Preparedness, Infrastructure and Communication. While the communication on government’s part was satisfactory, a lot was needed to be done in preparedness, he opined.

Click here to read the full transcript of his speech

 

In Lok Sabha, Saugata Roy said that huge loss of life and properties has happened in Nepal. It is good Indian govt has sent relief material to Nepal. He appreciated the central government’s role in relief operations but said a lot more could be done.

He also wanted to know from the government how much funds have been released from the National Disaster Relief Fund.

Click here to read the full transcript of his speech

 

The image is a representative one (courtesy: qz.com)

Derek O’Brien speaks on the earthquake tragedy in Nepal and India | Full Transcript

Full Transcript

Deputy Speaker Sir,

Desmond Doig, the famous journalist who lived in Kolkata and spent most of his time in Kathmandu in Nepal – he died many years ago – remembered the country for the comforting vision of Nepal with its emerald fields and terracotta huts and purple rain. In the last two days what we saw was anything but comforting.

On behalf of everyone in the country, as well as West Bengal, where we had casualties, we convey our deepest sympathies to the families of those who lost their lives.

Sir, for such a situation like this, our belief is that, the formula has to be PIC – Preparedness, Infrastructure and Communication. Since it is a different country, I should not comment on infrastructure. We should also prepare ourselves for facing disasters like these.

From an Indian point of view, our learning yesterday was, whether it was central government or the state government – governments of UP, Bengal and Bihar – the communication was very, very strong. Whether it was the Chief Minister of Bengal or the Prime Minister’s Office or other offices, communication went out well.

It is my duty to inform this House what happened in Bengal in terms of rescue. The disaster management teams were monitoring the situation. Everyone forgot about the local municipal elections. The administration was very focussed on the rescue efforts.

Disaster management meetings were chaired by the Chief Minister and the teams went out that evening. Everyone was very concerned. 15 mountaineers from Bengal came back safely.

Yesterday the Chief Minister of Bengal was in north Bengal, monitoring the situation. She had the opportunity to meet the families of those who had lost their lives.

The communication efforts, the disaster management efforts, specially up in north Bengal – Siliguri, Jalpaiguri, Darjeeling – were very well handled. In these situations, we always look up to the Army, Navy and the Air Force. They must also be congratulated.

I want to end with a suggestion, Sir. The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) was dissolved. Not that having an NDMA would have solved the earthquake problem, but out of a board of 12 odd members, only three members have been appointed so far. My humble suggestion to the government is not to keep those seats vacant.

Our prayers and thoughts are with the people of Nepal and the people of the States which are affected.

Vivek Gupta makes Special Mention demanding for declaring the Ganga Sagar Island a National Heritage Site | Full Transcript

Full Transcript

Mr. Vice-Chairman, Sir, I thank you very much for giving me this opportunity to speak on this issue.

Sir, there is a very famous saying, “Sab tirtha bar bar, Ganga sagar ek bar”. This phrase itself speaks the laurels of the historic heritage of the Ganga Sagar Island in the Sundarban Biosphere. The Ganga Heritage River Cruise Circuit is an initiative by the Government of West Bengal for identifying, preserving and promoting art, tradition, heritage, culture and environment as thrust areas for development of Indian culture and tourism.

Sir, the Ganga Sagar pilgrimage and fair is the second largest congregation after the holy Kumbh where over five lakh people take a holy dip on a single day of Makar Sankranti. The tirthasthan and the Kumbh Mela attract an annual footfall of 15-20 lakhs. The Government of West Bengal has connected the villages in the Sagar Islands with electricity through aerial wires across the river – the first ever initiative of its kind in the country.

Sir, West Bengal is the final recipient of all upstream pollution of River Ganga, while West Bengal is leading in Clean Ganga Mission, having completed 24 out of the 30 sanctioned projects implemented in 24 towns across the State. The previous Government had sanctioned Rs.1,200 crore for West Bengal under NGRBA, however no amount has been allocated to West Bengal under the Namami Ganga either in 2014 or in 2015.

Sir, tourism boosts the socio-economic development of the people in the region. The Ganga Sagar, as a place of religious importance and a hub for tourism and promotion of Indian culture, should be declared as a National Heritage Site. Sir, through you, I would like to draw the Government’s attention to this.

Thank you, Sir.

WB CM hails Right of Transgender Persons Bill passed in RS

West Bengal Chief Minister Ms Mamata Banerjee today tweeted in favour of the historic The Right of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014 passed in Rajya Sabha.

This is the first Private Members’ Bill to be passed in 46 years. “The Bill calls for setting up of commissions at state and central level. Bengal has already set up a Transgender Development Board,” she said in a tweet.

“Tamil Nadu & Bengal have always taken the lead in transgender welfare. Educational institutions in Bengal have also recognized third gender. More power and independence to transgender community. Happy that Bengal pioneered the concept of Transgender Welfare Board on 18 March, 2015” she added.

Bengal’s Transgender Development Board 

West Bengal government set up India’s first Transgender Development Board on the initiative of the West Bengal Chief Minister Ms Mamata Banerjee who is very much concerned for this section of the people.

The Board will have 12 persons, to be headed by a Chairperson. This Board will represent various transgender communities in the state and coordinate with the State’s Coordination Committee, which will be headed by the Minister of Women and Child Development.

The Board will distribute Identification Cards to the members of the transgender community, taking care of education, health and employment related issues. They will uphold all Rights as Citizens of India for their people and take care of the population census too.

Sukhendu Sekhar Roy speaks during a discussion on farmers’ distress and crisis | Full Transcript

Full Transcript

Sir, on behalf of my party All India Trinamool Congress, I join the honourable members in expressing our deep concern, grief and anguish over the suicide of farmers almost in every part of country. This is going on unabated.

Sir, according to a recent report published by the Centre for Human Rights and Global Justice, at New York University, it appears that over the past 15 years, suicides have claimed the lives of over 2,50,000 farming families in India and the death count is still climbing. Sir, according to that report, in every 30 minutes farmer suicides are happening.

What is the latest situation? In 2014 alone, as per the government figures, 1109 suicides took place. Out of those, 986 took place in Maharashtra, 184 in Telangana and 29 in Jharkhand. Even in Delhi and Rajasthan, yesterday farmers committed suicide. We are not here for a blame game but want to focus on the issue – the unprecedented crisis that India is confronted with.

Sir, there are several reasons why farmers are committing suicide. I would like to mention the main reasons, according to me. 40% farmers are in debt according to some research reports. Cost of inputs is increasing faster than cost of produce. Droughts and floods are occurring every five years, affecting 40% of the agricultural land in different parts of the country. More than 60% of the agricultural land in India, even after 67 years after independence, is dependent on rainfall. Some of the irrigation projects have not been completed for 20 years. Average net profit on one acre of land growing cereals is Rs 5000 only.

Therefore, the farmers are not getting remunerative prices. Not in Punjab, not only in Uttar Pradesh or Telangana. It is a common cause in every State of India. I will come to how West Bengal has combated this situation.

I would like to read one line from page 13 of the Election Manifesto of BJP before Lok Sabha elections. “Agriculture: Scientific, productive and rewarding.” They have assured the nation, before coming to power, that they will make agriculture scientific, productive and rewarding. To elucidate that point they also said: “The government, if they come to power, will ensure minimum 50% profits over the cost of production.” Here is a pledge before the nation by the ruling party. I would like to know from the government, the honourable ministers in charge of agriculture, food and other ministries, what is the roadmap of the government ensure minimum 50% profits over the cost of production.

This is main cause of concern. Farmers are not getting remunerative price. They are taking loans in the hope, they are yielding, thinking that next year they will yield, get remunerative price and pay off the debts. Nothing is coming out. Therefore, the only alternative left to marginal farmers is to commit suicide.

I am not blaming anybody but the government must address the situation. My government in West Bengal, under the leadership of Mamata Banerjee, was confronted with some problem of not getting of remunerative prices by potato farmers. The Chief Minister of West Bengal herself announced on 4 March, 2015, that 50 000 metric tonnes of potato will be directly procured from farmers, from 8 major potato-producing districts, at the rate of Rs 5500 per metric tonne. After procuring potatoes, the government is distributing them to schools for mid-day meal programme and beneficiaries of ICDS at the rate of 1 kg per head per week. This was announced on 11 March, 2015. If the government of West Bengal can do it, why can’t the government of India do it? This is the moot question.

The government of West Bengal has ensured the procurement of potatoes from farmers against only account payee cheques. This is a very transparent system. Till 21 April, 2015, 20,000 metric tonnes of potatoes have been procured and farmers have been paid by account payee cheques to sustain themselves. Potatoes are also being procured at the rate of Rs 550/quintal and 6000 quintals of potatoes have been procured so far. This apart, transport subsidy scheme has been introduced for interested potato traders and transporters.

To ease the stockpiling of farm produce, the government of West Bengal has requested the government of India on 9 April, 2015, to purchase one lakh metric tonnes of potatoes from farmers at minimum price of Rs 5500/metric tonne, the rate at which state government is purchasing. The Chief Minister wrote to the Union Finance Minister. To relieve the potato growers of economic hardship, the Chief Minister herself requested the government of India to waive the crop loans issued to potato growers during 2014-15 potato season and also to arrange fresh loans for the ensuing Kharif session.

So, these are some measures taken by the West Bengal government to come to the rescue of potato farmers. This is not just the case of potato farmers. If you look at a bigger canvas, the all-India perspective, you will find that the issue is same everywhere. Particularly the marginal farmers are subjected to such unprecedented crisis. The government must come up with a concrete and definite proposal and also announce it before the House. The House wants to know from the ruling party, it is a need of the hour to arrest the situation where the farmers are compelled to commit suicide.

On one hand we are claiming that we are going ahead with economic growth, claiming we will cross the economic growth of China. And then there are such tragic events like that of yesterday. This government has extended reliefs worth almost Rs 15,000 crores to the corporate in the form of tax waivers and other incentives. Why should such waivers not be extended to farmers? Farmers are crying for help with folded hands.

I urge the government to come up with a definite proposal with a proper roadmap and a timeframe to solve this crisis of farmers.

Thank you.

Derek O’Brien speaks during farewell to retiring members | Full Transcript

 Full Transcript

Stranger things have happened in Parliamentary democracy where somebody from my party stands up by choice and not by compulsion to bid a warm farewell to two MPs from the CPI(M) and CPI. I do this, as I said, by choice not by compulsion. This is the greatness parliamentary democracy of our. We may have serious differences with their ideology and despise them politically, but when we walk in through these doors, in the best way possible, we try and participate in the parliamentary democracy.

So, a very warm welcome back to Mr Ravi and a very warm farewell Mr Achuthan and very especially to P Rajeeve. During UPA II, we were working pretty much together on a number of things. Now that things have changed, we are still in the middle. We wish them well. We wish them happiness in whatever they do and all the best to the families.

I want to end by giving you a piece of information which I think is very important for the House. What does P in P Rajeeve’s name stand for? I have that answer. The P stands for Parliamentary Rajeeve.

RS: Trinamool opposes statement by minister on draconian land ordinance

Trinamool Congress today strongly protested against the Statement by Minister explaining the circumstances which had necessitated immediate legislation by promulgation of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Ordinance, 2015.

Voicing the party’s dissent to the draconian law, the leader of the party in Rajya Sabha, Derek O’Brien said this anti-farmer, anti-people ordinance must be scrapped. He added that Trinamool has been consistent in its opposition to the draconian land bill.

As a token of protest, a Trinamool MP also tore up the agenda papers which listed the statement by minister in business for the day.

SS Roy speaks during discussion on Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Bill, 2015 | Transcript

Full transcript:

Sir,

I would like to make a few quick points in the form of suggestions to the Government.

First of all, in our opinion a certain portion of the revenue should go to the State Government. The additional levy is also a compensatory amount, as stated in the paragraph 40 of the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, dated 24 September, 2014. The Government should consider that a certain portion of the additional levy should go to the coal producing state also.

Sir, my second point is that this Bill seeks to transfer the land and mine infrastructure to the new allottee. Clause 3J defines that mine infrastructure to include land demarcated for afforestation and land for rehabilitation and resettlement of persons affected by coal mining operations under the relevant Law. My suggestion is that that some provisions should be made in the rules so that land for afforestation and rehabilitation is not hampered and that should not be used for any other purposes.

Sir, my third point is that, as per Clause 17(3), the statutory powers of the state governments are sought to be suspended for an indefinite period. Sir, this may encroach upon the rights of the state. I would suggest the Government, before suspension of termination of license lease of mining,  should consult with the state government.

Sir, my next point is that the Government through this Bill also seeks to adopt a transparent system through e-auction which is a welcomed move. Still even after adoption of e-auction, report of cartelisation is appearing almost every day. Here the Competition Commission of India can play a very vital role provided the Government makes the Competition Commission of India more functional.

Sir, my next point is if we consider Clause 3 (1G) and read Clause 11 of the section 2 of Company’s Act 2013, then Sir, one will find that corporations have been included for the purpose of entering into the building.

Sir, as per the definition of Clause 11 of Section 2 of Company’s Act 2013, corporation includes foreign entity, companies which are registered outside India. Therefore my suggestion would be in the rules to be prescribed some provision should be made for some reasonable restrictions on the part foreign entities. There should not be any blanket authority in entering process.

Finally Sir, seeing the mines belonging to the states where its situated, the states must be consulted in the decision making process, even otherwise, consultation is a pre-condition of any liberal democracy. Therefore I urge upon the Government to take the views of the state governments in making decisions regarding allocation.

Thank you

TMC supports Govt on Mines & Coal Bill with constructive suggestions

Derek O’Brien today spoke on the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2015 in Rajya Sabha, where he said his party has taken the positive approach to the Bill.

Though the party supports the Bill in general but is concerned on certain issues of mining areas being environment friendly, implementing scientific methods for mining and setting up of regulatory mechanism for it.

Derek O’Brien also welcomed the idea of e-auction due to its transparency and gave the instance of West Bengal increasing revenues in the last three years by 87% through e-governance.

He supported the Mines & Minerals and Coal Bills but asked the Government to keep away from the Land Bill calling it a danger zone to step into.

Click here for the full speech of Derek O’Brien. 

Sukhendu Sekhar Ray spoke on the Coal Mines Bill 2015. He gave constructive suggestions to the Bill. He asked the Government to make decisions in consultation with the state governments.

SS Ray said, “Consultation is a pre-condition of any liberal democracy, therefore I urge upon the Government to take the views of the state government in taking decisions in regard to allocation.”

He also suggested the Central Government to share a part of additional levy with the coal producing state and cited the Supreme Court Judgement dated 24 September, 2014.

Click here for the full speech of Sukhendu Sekhar Ray.

Derek O’Brien speaks during discussion on Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2015 | Transcript

Full transcript:

Sir, there are two ways of looking at this Mines and Minerals Bill after it has come from the Select Committee. One way of looking at it Sir, there is a glass of water which is half full and the other way of looking at it is that the glass of water is half empty.

My party believes in looking at this Bill in a positive way and has given some suggestions which have been incorporated. So let us be optimistic and say the glass is half full, let us not be negative.

Sir, there are five specific points I will make in three minutes as these are five parameters according to which we should judge this Bill.

First, local communities as partners of development. Here we gave the Government last week a specific suggestion on the floor of the House to allow the District Mineral Foundation set up by the State Government to include tribals because then the tribals will also feel they are part of the whole system. Tribals have been historically neglected. This is not the ideal solution but it is close, as I said the glass is half full.

The states have also been empowered to set up special courts for quick settlement for mining disputes and I am also glad that the entire composition of the DMF has been given to the state governments. Thank you for including that in the Bill.

The second point Sir, is to capture the windfall of profit within the nation, the state and the people. Here again in our own experience in West Bengal we have seen through e-governance we have actually increased revenues by 87% in the last three years. So we welcome the concept of e-auction, it is a transparent process. These are the good things.

On the other issues Sir, there is no regulatory mechanism for mining as yet. Now for environment friendly mines, I want to make a point which you have not included in the Bill but please think about including it and updating the 2011 rules because 80% of the mines today are not environment friendly. If you look at the rules, the environment Minister is here. Those rules call for 20 years and 30 years but now it has gone up to 50 years. Please look at those rules very carefully.

The other one Sir, is the scientific mining procedures for the future. That is the other reason why again the National Mineral Exploration Trust needs to do this.

Overall Sir we are going with this Bill, we are supporting this Bill. However at this stage I also want to say please pass the Mining and Mineral and subsequently the Coal Bill, but do not touch the Land Bill, the land is a different kind of mine, that is a land mine, it will explode. Stay away from the land mine of the Land Bill, you have some support from us now, very good, do the job but please do not touch the Land Bill.

Thank you Sir.