March 28, 2022
Saugata Roy opposed the introduction of The Criminal Procedure (Identification) Bill, 2022
Sir, under Rule 72 (1), I rise to oppose the introduction of the Criminal Procedure (Identification) Bill, 2022. I do not want to repeat the arguments put forward by learned Members, Shri Manish Tewari and Shri N. K. Premachandran.
Sir, you will know from common sense that it is the basic principle of law that nobody is found guilty unless proved in a court of law. The second right that people have is, if somebody is arrested, he has to be produced before the court within 24 hours and he has a right to be represented by a lawyer. Now, so far, since when the original Bill is there 1920, it has been going on. Suddenly, it comes to the brain of the Home Minister that he must make it stricter and he must take finger prints, iris photographs and biological samples. Why? Sir, why should there be narco analysis brain mapping? अचानक क्या ज�रत पड़ गई, क्या अचानक क्राइम बढ़ गया है ? Sir, you know that, from Articles 20 to 24, all the Articles of the Constitution deal with the human rights of the people. This law which allows for narco
analysis, which allows for taking biological specimens and taking photographs of iris violates the basic human rights and is against the principles of the Constitution. सर, आपनेअभी कहा िक अपनी बात को िबल पर चचार् के समय मेंउठाइए। लेिकन इं ट्रोडक्शन के नाम पर एक गलत िबल आपके सामनेलाया जाए, तो यह सरासर हाउस के िखलाफ होगा, इससेहाउस का नु
कसान होगा। इसिलए मैंआपसेअजर्करता ह�ँिक इसका इं ट्रोडक्शन मत होनेदीिजए। होम िमिनस्टर आए, ं वेएक्सप्ले न कर।
ें श्री टेनी जी क्या समझाएगं े, होम िमिनस्टर को समझानेक� ज�रत है। धन्यवाद
