Rajya Sabha MP Sukhendu Sekhar Ray’s Point of Order under Rules 266 and 176, urging the Chair to convert his notice under Rule 267 into a short duration discussion under Rule 176 by using the Chair’s discretion under Rule 266, as per a precedent set on July 29, 2024

Sir, I have a point of order. I have only one submission to make because during the Zero Hour, normally, we do not raise point of order. Since your honour has directed me to raise the point of order… Sir, it is under Rules 266 and 176. Actually, last year, on 29th July, there was precedence when your honour was pleased to convert notice under Rule 267 into notice under Rule 176 for a Short Duration Discussion on the tragic death of students in a coaching institute in Delhi. So, I am requesting your honour to kindly convert my notice under 267 into notice under Rule 176 by exercising your discretionary power under Rule 266 for a Short Duration Discussion on the subject that I have raised through my notice under Rule 267. That is my humble submission and request to your honour to consider. suggestion. I will take it into consideration and take a call and indicate so. Now, Matters raised with permission, Dr. John Brittas on ‘Demand to assist Kerala in rehabilitating the landslide victims in Wayanad district’.

Lok Sabha MP Pratima Mondal’s speech during the discussion and voting on the demands for grants, through the Union Budget, under the control of the Ministry of Jal Shakti for 2025-26

Madam, on behalf of the All India Trinamool Congress, I rise to speak on the Demands for Grants of the Ministry of Jal Shakti for the year 2025-26. I would like to express my concern regarding the functioning of the Ministry of Jal Shakti. It was envisioned that this Ministry would be effective in addressing India’s multifaceted water challenges, including water scarcity, sanitation and the provision of clean drinking water. Madam, water is the driving force of nature. It is the most precious resource and abundant compound on earth’s surface, covering more than 70 per cent of the planet. But India has only four per cent of water whereas it is home to 17 per cent of the world population. Now, it is evident that the ratio of availability and usage is not at the desired level. The solution lies in smart usage. Unfortunately, it has clearly failed in doing so. It is highlighted in the 2018 report published by the NITI Aayog that at least 21 major Indian cities, including New Delhi, were projected to exhaust their groundwater resources by 2020. If that is the case, I would like to know from the hon. Minister how we are going to move forward from here. Madam, the Ministry has seen a significant rise in the funds allocated to it. For the financial year of 2024-25, Rs.98,418 crore was given. In the Union Budget, for the fiscal year 2025-26, the Ministry of Jal Shakti has been allocated Rs.99,503 crore. These allocations represent approximately 1.964 per cent of the total Government expenditure, positioning the Ministry of Jal Shakti among the key sectors in terms of budgetary priority. Madam, despite this, there is a significant underutilization of this fund. So, I would like to ask the hon. Minister the reason for non-utilization of the fund. The ambitious Har Ghar Jal initiative that aims to provide every rural household with tap water by 2024 has now been extended till 2028. I would like to know from the hon. Minister why the Government needs four years more to fulfil its target. I would also like to highlight an important issue. The Ministry claimed that 78 per cent of Anganwadi centres had access to clean tap water under the Jal Jeevan Mission. However, this was based on a total of 11.11 lakh centres, while the Ministry of Women and Child Development reported that there are 13.87 lakh operational centres as of March 2021. Is there a valid explanation for this glaring mismatch in number? Such differences raise doubt about the accuracy of the Ministry’s data and the transparency of its reporting. This means that about 2.75 lakh centres were left out, bringing the actual coverage down to around 70 per cent. The Ministry’s focus on large-scale water infrastructure projects, such as river interlinking project, which aims to connect 37 rivers and extensive dam construction, gives rise to various environmental and social concerns. These projects can harm ecosystems, displace communities and lead to loss of biodiversity. I urge the Ministry to focus on sustainable communitybased water management instead of large infrastructure projects that could cause long-term damage. … Madam, my Party has given 15 minutes for me. I would like to know from the hon. Minister whether the waters of the Ganga River in Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh, during the ongoing Maha Kumbh were completely clean? As per the National Green Tribunal’s directives, millions of devotees should have been informed about the quality of the water they were about to dip into. We have all seen the reports showing dangerously high levels of bacteria in the water, making it unsafe for bathing. If the Minister has received this information, I would like to know from the Government what steps the Government is taking regarding cleaning the Ganga Triveni Sangam. Madam, I belong to the Sundarbans Constituency. The Sundarbans river embankment issue is a major challenge due to the region’s fragile ecosystem. The region faced constant threats from cyclones like Amphan, Aila, Bulbul, Yaas and many more. The Government of India sanctioned Rs 2,103.64 crore for FMP schemes, namely Sundarban Embankments Reconstruction Project, KaliaghaiKapaleswari-Baghai Basin Scheme etc., The Government of West Bengal submitted a reimbursement project worth Rs. 204.07 crore, but only Rs. 44.15 crore has so far been reimbursed. So, I would like to request the hon. Minister to release the balance amount, that is, Rs. 159.92 crore at the earliest. I would like to request the hon. Minister to implement the Ghatal Master Plan which is a long-pending demand of the people in the two flood-affected districts. The dredging of Bhagirathi, Hooghly and Ganga at the upstream of Farakka Barrage to maintain navigability at Kolkata port was the main objective of construction of Farakka Barrage and Ganga Water Treaty, 1996. So, I would like to request the hon. Minister to release the fund. The three North Bengal districts, namely, Cooch Behar, Alipurduar and Jalpaiguri, which are criss-crossed by more than 50 rivers having their origin in Bhutan, are mainly responsible for erosion and flood. So, I would like to request the hon. Minister that since the Government of West Bengal has already sent a proposal and requested for sanctioning of fund on 8th August, 2024, you should constitute an Indo-Bhutan Joint River Commission at the earliest to formulate and recommend flood control works and flood warning system. Being a representative of Sundarbans, I would like to request the hon. Minister to sanction more fund for construction and maintenance of the entire river embankment of Sundarbans to protect the people of Sundarbans. Thank you, Madam.

Lok Sabha MP Pratima Mondal’s Zero Hour mention on the demand for a railway line from the town of Jaynagar to Maipith via Jamtala in her constituency of Jaynagar

Madam, I would like to draw the attention of this House to a matter of public importance. Madam, Joynagar-II block and Kultali, both fall under my Parliamentary Constituency, which is a completely rural area. The total population of the said area is more than five lakhs. The people have been deprived of availing the railway facility since Independence. The total distance from the last station from Joynagar to Moipithis around 50 kilometres. Therefore, the students have no option but to shift to other locations for their higher studies. I would like to request the hon. Railway Minister to introduce a new railway line project from Joynagar to Moipith via Jamtala for the greater interest of the lakhs of people living in this local area. Thank you.

Lok Sabha MP Asit Kumar Mal’s Zero Hour mention on the demand for funds for Awas Yojana and MGNREGS (100 Days’ Work) for Bengal

Thank you, Madam for giving me an opportunity. I would like to draw your kind attention to the fact that each and every State of India gets money for Awas Yojana, but only West Bengal is deprived of the funds of Awas Yojana for several years. The hon. Chief Minister of West Bengal has given Rs. 60,000per beneficiary as first instalment. There are a total of 12 lakh beneficiaries under the Awas Yojana (Banglar Bari). You will be glad to know that recently in the Budget Session, hon. Chief Minister, Mamata Banerjee has allotted funds for 16 lakh Awas Yojana beneficiaries, besides, the West Bengal Government has already paid the wages of 28 lakh 100-day job workers. If the Central Government would pay these funds, then the West Bengal Government could give more effective service to the poor people of West Bengal. I, therefore, want to make this request. Let the hon. Prime Minister allot funds for Awas Yojana and 100-day job for the workers of West Bengal.

Lok Sabha MP Kirti Azad’s supplementary question on the government’s efforts to protect children and the youth from the harmful effects of addiction to online gaming and gambling

अध्यक्ष महोदय, ऑनलाइन गैंबदलंग, मतलब जआु ही होता है। इसको अंग्रेजी मेंऑनलाइन गैंबदलंग का नाम ददया है। मैंमाननीय मंत्री जी का जवाब सनु रहा था और मझुेउनका जवाब अच्छा लगा। मैंकुछेक चीजों केबारेमेंजानना चाहता था। उन्होंनेकहा दक ऑथराइज्ि या अनऑथराइज्ि, लेदकन गैंबदलंग, गैंबदलंग होता है, वह चाहेऑथराइज्ि हो या अनऑथराइज्ि हो। लगभग20 साल पहलेदसंगल दिदज‍िट लॉटररयों कोबंद करवायागया था। उसकी यहांपर बहुत बड़ी मदुहम चली थी। उसकेबाद हीवह काम हो पाया था। आजकल हम देखतेहैंदक बोििऑफ कं ट्ोल फॉर दिकेट इन इंदिया मेंभी स्पॉन्ससिहैं, जो कहतेहैंदक आप टीम बनाइए और पैसेकमाइए। अध्यक्ष जी, ऐसेमेंमैंयह जानना चाहता ह ूँदक अनेक लोग पैसेनहीं चकुा पाए। उन्होंनेआत्महत्या कर ली। घर सेमाूँकी ज्वैलरी चोरी की, उसको बेचा, हत्याएंकीं। इसको लेकर हमारेदेश के यवुा बबािद हो रहेहैं। इसदलए इसमेंजैसा दक माननीय मंत्री जी नेकहा, वहदबल्कुल सहीहैदक राज्यों की भीइसमेंभागीदारीहोतीहै, लेदकन येबच्चेहमारे देश केहैं। इन बच्चों के ऊपर जो बरुा असर हो रहा है, जो पररवार बबािद हो रहेहैं, जो आत्महत्या कर रहेहैं, जो चोरी-चकारी और िकैती कर रहेहैं, उसको रोकनेके दलए सामूदहक रूप सेमैंमंत्री जी जानना चाह ंगा दक वेक्या कर रहेहैं, दजससेहमारेदेश केबच्चेबबािद न हों?

Rajya Sabha MP Sukhendu Sekhar Ray’s speech during the discussion on the working of the MInistry of Health and Family Welfare

But when I, as an old man, look at the health sector of the country, I feel utter shock and desperation. Why has this feeling crept in my mind? Madam, according to Global Cancer Observatory estimates, there were 19.3 million cancer cases worldwide in 2020, and India ranked third after China and USA. GLOBOCON, 2022 Report also predicted that cancer cases in India would increase to 2.08 million, accounting for a rise of 57.5 per cent in 2040 from 2020. Madam, apart from cancer, the major diseases which cause deaths in India are ischemic heart diseases, cardiovascular diseases, respiratory diseases, tuberculosis, diabetes, liver, kidney and asthma diseases, indicated by World Health Organization data published in May, 2024. Even the hon. Prime Minister, on the other day, expressed his serious concern about the steep rise in obesity. Madam, with the mushroom growth of private nursing homes and clinics, the sale of spurious and substandard medicines is skyrocketing. The Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation also found more than 50 products as ‘not of standard quality.’ This finding of CDSCO came even after banning of 344 drugs in 2016 and 156 FDC drugs last year by the Government. please consider setting up a Combined Combat Force with personnel from the Central and State Governments to initiate a nationwide crackdown on the units and agents engaged in manufacturing and sale of spurious and banned medicines. They are the real enemies within the country who are destroying people’s health. Government is greasing the oily heads. Madam, the Government has allocated Rs. 95,957 crores to the health sector for Fiscal Year, 2026, that is, 9.46 per cent increase from the 2025 Budget. But it does little to address the long-standing resource gap in public health infrastructure because the healthcare sector accounts for 1.94 per cent of the total Budget reflecting a declining trend compared to previous years. Madam, despite the rising cost of medicines and treatment, there was a legitimate expectation among the people across the nation, particularly, the senior citizens, missing middle class families and the workers from the informal sector that there would be reduction of GST on health insurance premiums from 18 per cent to 5 per cent and the TDS limit under Section 80 of the IT Act will increase from Rs. 25,000 to Rs. 50,000 but in vain. Now, let me talk about my State, West Bengal, for a while. The hon. Chief Minister of West Bengal, Mamata Didi, had introduced Swasthya Sathi in December, 2016, long before the introduction of Ayushman Bharat by the Government of India. The Swasthya Sathi was acclaimed worldwide like many other welfare schemes undertaken under the aegis of didi. Today, 2914 hospitals in Bengal are empanelled in Swasthya Sathi. In 2021-22, the spending on account of Swasthya Sathi was Rs. 2,263 crore, which went up to Rs. 2,694 crore in 2023-24, immensely benefiting over 8.72 crore people till February this year. We are happy that the Government of India and some other States are following the innovative healthcare measures of didi. Let there be healthy competition to ensure welfare of the common people, the marginalised and the backward classes who have been suffering for centuries in the absence of proper nutrition and healthcare. Madam, at the same time, I am putting a question to myself as to why there should be a step-motherly attitude by the Centre towards Bengal. West Bengal is an integral part of India, that is, Bharat, which is a Union of States, as envisaged in the first Article of the Constitution of India. It was never and can never be a unitary state. The history of 190-year British rule is witness to the valiant liberation war launched by the people of Bengal, from the Battle of Plassey in 1757 by Nawab Siraj-ud-daula to the Sepoy Mutiny in 1857 at Barrackpore, led by Mangal Pandey, from the revolutionary upsurge organized by Shri Autobindo, Khudiram, Bagha Jatin, Master Da Surja Sen, Rash Behari Bose and many others, which culminated into ‘war’ declared by the Supreme Commander of Indian National Army, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose against the British on October 21, 1943 and unfurled the National Flag on the Andaman and Nicobar Islands as well as in Mairang, now in Meghalaya. More than three million Bengalis died of manmade famine in 1943. To add salt to our injuries, Bengal was partitioned and millions of people became refugees overnight. It continued and it took three generations to settle down and to live with human dignity. Why should we be discriminated against even after 75 years of Independence? Let me quickly refer to the funding under the National Health Mission and PMMYV of the Central Government. No fund under NHM has been released by the Government of India since August, 2023 in spite of fulfilment of all conditions. Similarly, no fund has been released by the Ministry of Women and Child Development since November, 2022 under the Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana, not to speak of Rs. two lakh crore, which is due and payable by the Government of India on account of MNREGA, Awas Yojana and other Centrally-sponsored schemes compelling the Bengal Government to continue with the schemes out of its own fund. I had never witnessed such an inimical attitude by the Centre towards the poor people of Bengal in the 58 years of my political life. This is going too far. DEFG HIF JKLMNO PQEIF RO SN TUVI WH SXYR ZG[ZI\ RG ]^FI_ N`aहNIaEI T\IP [GEOc Before I conclude, I would urge upon the Government to take care of the increasing environmental hazards, rampant use of dangerous chemical components in fertilizers, insecticides and pesticides used in farming. Organic farming continues to be a myth.

 

May the winds blow sweetly, May the rivers flow sweetly, May the herbs be to us sweet and beneficial, May there be sweetness during the day and night, May the heaven be sweet to us, May the fruit bearing trees be sweet to us, May the sun be sweet and benevolent to us.

Rajya Sabha MP Ritabrata Banerjee’s supplementaries on his starred question on the amounts owed to the government by wilful defaulters and the action taken against them, and details on the recapitalisation measures undertaken by the government for public-sector banks with a high volume of non-performing assets (NPA)

Sir, roughly, loans worth around Rs. 12 lakh crore have been written off by the nationalized banks. From the answer, we gather that the amount of recovered loans is Rs. 1,26,000- plus, that is, roughly ten per cent. Through you, Sir, I would like to know if the hon. Minister could provide the House with the details of the top 20 wilful defaulters in India as on date and state specifically what action has been taken to recover the outstanding amounts from these wilful defaulters. It will be greatly appreciated if the hon. Minister could furnish a written response on this with details. Sir, my specific question was about the nationalised banks. Overall, Rs.16.35 lakh crores have been written off. Out of this amount, Rs.12 lakh crores were of nationalised banks. The answer given by the Government shows that the recovery is of Rs.1,26,000 crore, that is, merely 10 per cent. So, 90 per cent of the loans is not recovered. Now, my second supplementary, through you, is this. Could the Minister state the details of the cases where the Government has taken recapitalisation measures for public sector banks facing a high volume of Non-Performing Assets? Please also state the details of the funds for recapitalisation released to these banks in the last five years. I will urge, through you, that I need a specific answer. The earlier answer was not at all specific.

Rajya Sabha MP Sushmita Dev’s supplementary question on efforts, if any, being made by the government to hire contractual staff to fill up health posts in the northeast as postings in that region are often seen by people from other regions as hardships postings and therefore, not worth it, and addressing the striking National Health Mission workers in Assam on the issue of ‘equal pay, equal work’

Thank you, Sir, for the opportunity. I have gone through the list of sanctioned posts and the vacancies. There are three units in Silcher, but the figure against sanctioned posts is zero. Therefore, they have not been able to fill it. My question to the hon. Minister is this: A posting in the North East is seen in the country as a hardship posting sometimes. So, does the Health Minister have any provision to, maybe, hire doctors, paramedics on a contractual basis rather than filling up these permanent posts, which may help in better human resource?