Abir Ranjan Biswas’s Supplementary Questions on regulating milk price, esp. to help children, and removal of GST on milk products

Sir, we know that as far as child nutrition is concerned, milk is a cheap source. From the reply given by the Minister, it seems that he is heavily dependent on the Poshan Scheme. I would like to bring to the notice of the Minister that this scheme has not been a very good
success. They have a target of arresting stunted growth to 25 per cent by 2022. The current NFHS-5 figures show that it has achieved only 35.5 per cent. That is just an example, Sir. I may again repeat that milk is a cheap source of nutrition for children aged below six years. The Minister has said that the Government does not regulate milk prices. Does the Minister intend to do something more to help out in this case the people, especially children, of the lower income group? Sir, I would be putting my second supplementary question, but as I said, the Poshan Abhiyan has not been a good success and hence I was asking if Government intends to do something more. Sir, this is my second supplementary question. As per the answer and as per several news articles, milk inflation increased to 7.7 per cent in October, 2022. I would like to know if the Minister has requested or intends to request the Finance Ministry to remove the five per cent GST on curd, lassi, buttermilk and 12 per cent GST on condensed milk, butter, ghee, cheese, etc., for easy accessibility to the lower income groups.

Md Nadimul Haque raised during Zero Hour the need for formulating an SOP for heirs of the deceased to claim their inheritance from banks

Sir, rightful heirs have a hard time claiming their inherited money usually present in the form of unclaimed bank deposits, insurance, Post Office funds, etc., because the process to retrieve them is often cumbersome and different for each entity and every bank. At present, the unclaimed sum is reportedly estimated at a massive Rs. 82,025 crore. Parliament has authorized the RBI to enact a policy or issue directions with a statutory backing. However, no redressal or actionable procedures have been formulated until now. What accelerates
the problem is the fact that individual banks make their own rules and demands to release these claims. For instance, they ask
for probate, sureties from unrelated person, indemnities, affidavits, mandatory fixed deposit, etc. Therefore, I request the Government to formulate a Standard Operating Procedure for making effective claims and for creating a more humane system for heirs of deceased persons to claim their inheritance. In addition, a centralised online database should be developed under the control of the RBI. That will provide information about the deceased account holders including their details. Further, in every nine to twelve months, banks should be asked to mandatorily inform the RBI about the inoperative or dormant bank accounts. I end by saying that this unclaimed public money, which is to the tune of more than Rs.82,000 crores, is the resource of the citizens. I am just concluding.  Okay, Sir. I would like to say that
this amount is the resource of the citizens and it is the duty of the Government that this resource, unclaimed money, goes back in the
fulfilment of the demands and various schemes of the citizens.

Kalyan Banerjee asked Supplementary Questions on setting up cancer detection facilities in rural areas and population-based cancer registration centres

Sir, the COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted non-COVID healthcare system, leading to concerns about the subsequent impact on non-COVID disease conditions. The diagnosis and treatment of cancer is also affected. Sir, since 31st May, 2020, there has been a reduction of 54 per cent in the number of patients registered; there has been a reduction of 46 per cent in follow-up visits; there has been a reduction of 36 per cent in hospital admissions; there has been a reduction of 37 per in out-patient chemotherapy cases; there has been a reduction of 52 per cent in minor surgery cases; there has been a reduction of 38 per cent reduction in pathological diagnosis cases and there has been a reduction of 43 per cent in radiological diagnosis cases. In this backdrop, I want to know whether the Government is having a plan to start Cancer Detection Centre and Initial Care Service in the rural primary health centres in the country, especially in the case of easy to detect earlier stage of breast and prostate cancer. : Sir, on my first supplementary on the rural and primary health centres, she has given some answers in respect of the cities. My second Supplementary is: whether the Government is having any plan to expand the scope and function of population based cancer registered centres which presently cover 10 per cent population of India from 38 centres to all major
cancer research hospitals of the States and districts in the country.

Sukhendu Sekhar Ray raised an objection to a Minister characterising a state government as ‘chor’ and asked whether this is admissible under the Rules

Sir, with your consent, I have raised the point of order. Rule 47, subrule ii says the right to ask a Question is governed by the following conditions. There are 22 conditions for the person who…. The Honorable Member who raised the Question. There is no such conditionality in so far the Ministers are concerned while getting the reply. Just now I have found that thus House has witnessed that in a reply to a Supplementary Question of Honorable Member Sanjay Singh the Honorable Minister characterized the state government as a ‘chor’, ‘theif’ government. Whether this is admissible under the rules, I put it for your kind consideration.

Jawhar Sircar’s Supplementary Question on the steps taken by the government to ensure adequate procurement of foodgrains for its schemes

Thank you, Sir, for this opportunity. I have only one simple and sharp question addressed to the hon. Minister. Are we heading for a food crisis? I have figures with me. Usually, we have stocks of about 25 million tonnes to 26 million tonnes of wheat at the beginning of
the year. We have around 29 million tonnes to 30 million tonnes of rice at the end of the year. Last year’s procurement was an all time record. But, in this current year and in the previous year, we have consumed a lot, thanks to the Prime Minister’s free ration scheme. The net question is that wheat has been impacted, as we know, by the heat wave and other factors. And, Sir, rice, paddy has also been badly
impacted. They have been reflected on the procurement figures. So, we are in shortage state, hon. Minister. And I would like the Government to admit it and take steps.

Shanta Chhetri’s Supplementary Questions on funds allotted for Darjeeling and Kalimpong districts under PM-MITRA scheme and rules for setting up textile parks

Sir, my first supplementary question is this.Under the Prime Minister Mega Integrated Textile Region and Apparel (PMMITRA) scheme, I would like to know whether the hon. Minister will specifically elaborate about the fund allotted and the project details for
Darjeeling and Kalimpong Districts. Sir, my second supplementary question is this. I would like to know whether the Textile Ministry, on its inspection, found Darjeeling or Kalimpong Districts suitable for setting up of a PMMITRA park. If yes, can the proposal still be sent by the State Government? And, what is the last date for submission of such a proposal? MR. CHAIRMAN: Now, the Minister. Please give pointed response.

Pratima Mondal raised under Rule 377 the issue of constructing a public toilet and water facilities at Canning railway station

Canning railway station is a suburban station which experiences heavy footfall daily. Not only does it serve the people of the rural area who travel to and fro to the city but also tourists. Since it is the gateway to Sundarbans, it holds a special importance as a mode of connectivity. The problem that I would like to put forth is related to basic human necessity. Canning railway station is in dire need of a public toilet. In the absence of a proper toilet, men are seen urinating in the surrounding areas and women have to suffer. People have to wait long hours just to use a restroom. This should not be happening. Thus, I request the hon. Minister to look into the matter and make provision for constructing a public toilet at Canning railway station.

Aparupa Poddar raised during Zero Hour the need for a halt station in Bolandi to service the people of the numerous villages in Arambagh and Khanakul blocks

Thank you Chairperson, Sir for allowing me to speak in Zero Hour. Sir today I will raise an apparently small issue but the issue is very significant for my constituency. I have been fighting for this since the 16th Lok Sabha. When our Chief Minister was the Railway
Minister, at that time along with Arambagh Bishnupur railways, it was also included in the survey – Bolondy Halt Station. The distance from Mayapur station to Arambagh station is 15 kms and there are 50 villages situated in between. However, even after raising this demand several times from 2014 to date, this station has not been operationalised. This is my humble request that it should be built urgently because the place Mayapur is frequented by not only people of Arambagh but also by people of Khanakul Blocks 1 and 2. Many people visit the place regularly. Therefore for their convenience and for celebrating the 250th birth anniversary of Raja Rammohan Roy, I demand that this bolondi Halt station may be built. The people of Khanakul would be highly benefitted if it happens. I am requesting the Railway Ministry again that it involves a very small amount but will be of use to the common people of the area. Thank you.

Saugata Roy raised during Zero Hour the issue of the attempts being made by the Union Government to run down the independence of the judiciary

Sir, I have already changed my subject, and I have already given notice for it. Sir, as you know the 99th Constitution Amendment striking down the National Judicial Appointment Commission, which was passed by this House was struck down by the Supreme Court as a result of which the collegium system of appointing Judges continues. Recently, our Law Minister has been snipping at the Supreme Court and
at the collegium system. We did not take him seriously because he is a talkative Minister, Mr. Kiren Rijiju. But now a person in high office, who cannot be criticised except by a substantive motion, has come out to criticise the striking down of the NJAC. The Government is trying to extend its power everywhere, including into the Judiciary. It is not finding the Judiciary pliable. That is why, it is using a high
dignitary to run down the Collegium system. At this point of time, our party believes that the Collegium system should continue, not that it is perfect. But the Collegium system of the Supreme Court is actually a bigger guarantee against the tyranny of the power by the Central Government. I oppose the comments made by the high authority and also by the Law Minister against the Supreme Court, and the Collegium system. We will oppose all efforts to run down the independence of the Judiciary, which is one of thepillars of the Constitution, which this Government is trying to bring down. … (Interruptions)