Rajya SabhaLok Sabha

February 5, 2018

Sukhendu Sekhar Roy speaks Motion of Thanks to the President’s Address

Sukhendu Sekhar Roy speaks Motion of Thanks to the President’s Address

FULL TRANSCRIPT

Sir, thank you very much. Sir, 29th January, Saansad ki Joint Session mein mananiya Rashtrapati ji 20 panna likhit bhashan mein kum se kum 11 Pradhan Mantri Yojana ka ullekh kiya. Jaise ki Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana, Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana, Pradhan Mantri Kisan Sampada Yojana: 11 yojanao ka ullekh kiya gaya, aur usmein kya nahi hai? Toilet bhi hai, digital wallet bhi hai. Start-up bhi hai, stand up bhi hai.

Lekin, start-up hui hai kya? Mera sawal yeh banta hai ki start-up hui hai kya? Aur stand up bhi hum janta kaise karenge kyun ki notebandi aur GST ke double dhamake se aam janta ka kamar toot gaya. Iska koi tareeka nahi diya gaya hai iss bhashan mein. Na toh yatra shuru kar paya aur na hi khare hone ki koshish kar sakti hai janta.

Iss saal kayi rajyon mein aur agle saal ki aam chunayon ko madde nazar rakhte huye, yeh budget bhi chunayovi jumla jaisa hai. Haala ki iss abhibhashan mein Mahamayi Rashtrapati ji ki mann ki baat nahi kahi gayi. Harr Ravivaar hum jo mann ki baat sunte hai, wahi dauharaya gaya is abhibhashan mein. Isse zyaada ismein kuch hai nahi.

Nayi do cheezen bataayi gayi: panna 19 mein bataaya gaya ki simultaneous election hona chahiye aur iske liye sadan ko iska vichaar karna chahiye. Kahaan se aaya yeh prastav? Chunaav Aayog ne aisa koi prastav diya hai kya? Constitution mein aisa koi pravdhaan hai kya? Koi mujhe dikha de ek bhi article, ek bhi provision kahin pe hai, jahaan bataya gaya hai ki kendrya aur rajya ki chunav ek saath karna padhega. Aur sann 1967 se aaj takk shayad hi kabhi kendrya aur rajya ka chunaav ek saath hua hai.

Toh achaanak aap log kendriya aur rajya ka election saath mein karne ke liye aap log shor machane lage kyun? Kyun ki aap samvidhaan ko jar se ukharna chahate hain. Ek naya samvidhan banana chahatein hai, aapke rajnitik swarth ke liye. Iska alag doosra koi karan nahi hai.

Bataye ja rahein hai ki samay ki barbaadi aur kharcha dono ho raha hai bahut. Aapne toh Digital India bana diya, online chunaav kar dijiye. Kharch aur samay dono bach jayenge. Mahine bhar chunaav, paramilitary deployment ki zaroorat nahi padegi. Aap Digital India kijiye. Yeh saare slogan, naarebaazi zyada din tak nahi chalega.

Page number 2 meh Mahamahim ji neh bola ki Triple Talak ka Bill saansad meh pass kiya jaega aur bataya gaya ki hum log virodh kar rahe the. Koi bhi party neh virodh nahi kiya, ek bhi virodhi dal neh virodh nahi kiya. Humare maange thi ki iss Bill meh kuch kamiya hai aur iss Bill ko Select Committee meh bheja jaaye aur scrutiny karne ke baad yaha wapas laya jai aur phir hum batchit karenge. Yeh ek Sansadiya pranali hai aur aap kyu iss sansadiya pranali ko barbaad karne chahatey hai? Iss ka jawab dijiye.
Bohut saare baat bataein gaye hain ki Hindustan bohut aage baad gaya hai lekin kitna aage baada hai? Mere paas do, teen reports hai UNDP development report- manav vikas ki hisaab seh duniya ke 188 desho meh Bharat ka sthan 131 hai matlab Bharat seh jaada manav vikas 130 desh meh hui hai.Humare saath tulna sirf Congo, Namibia aur padosi Pakistan seh kiya jaa sakta hai dusro desho seh nahi aisa humara development hua hai. Humare pasodi Sri Lanka aur Maldives bhi humse aage hai. Yeh UNDP ka report hai, Trinamool Congress ka nahi.

World Economic Forum inclusive development index 2018 hal hi meh nikla aur isske anusaar 6 out of 10 Indians still live on less then 3.20 dollar per day. Iss ka matlab kariban 78 crore Hindustani Rs 6000 mahina meh din gujaarte hai aur yaha GDP growth rate ka kahani sunaya jaa raha hai. CIA ek khufiya agency hai America ka CIA world fact report nikalte hai har saal duniya ki saare desho ka CIA world fact book yeh bola hai apni 29th January ko report nikla hai aur yeh pata chalta hai 1 number santaan paida karte samay garvavati mata ki mrityu ki sankhya meh duniya ki 180 desho ke andar Hindustan 56 number meh hai. Matlab matritakalin mrityu ki sankhya meh bhi humara desh seh 120 desh humse piche hai hum aage baad gaye hai. Kya aise hum naari sashaktikaran karna chahateh hai? Do, baal mrityu meh bhi Bharat 133 desho seh aage hai, 35.7% sishu jinke umar paanch saal seh kum hai woh chinta janak kum vajan ke hai aur iss kum vajan wale sishu ke sankhya meh Bharat duniya meh doosra sthan meh hai.

Abhi dekhiye Global Burden of Disease published in the medical journal ‘The Lancet’. Iss seh pata chalta hai 2016 meh Bharat meh paanch saal ki kum umar ka shishu ki mrityu sankhya 9 lakh ho gaya. Prati 1000 nagrik ko ek doctor ka bhi seva nahi milti hai aur yeh mera report nahi hai. Prati 1000 nagrik ko haspatal meh ek bhi bed nahi milti. Bharat meh 21 lakh janta ko HIV AIDS hai aur hum pure duniya meh tisri sthan meh hai. CIA report ke mutabik 71.5% gramin janta aur 37.4% shahari janta ko koi sanitation facility nahi milta toh Swach Bharat ka nara kyu laga rahe hai. Yeh naare-baji ki sarkar ko jawab degi janta agle election meh.

Aab mein thhori der ke liye is avivasan pe bhi nazar dhalna chahata hu. On page three, it is said, “My government is committed of doubling of farmers income by 2022.” BJP ke 2014 ke election manifesto mein bhi hai. Lekin char saal kyon double nahin hua., iska javaab koun dega. Iska javaab abhi chaar saal mein nahin aaya. Sirf 2015 mein 12,500 kisaano neh aatmahatya kiya. Har din 35 kisaan khudkushi karta hai on an average.
Chaar saal sarkar sothe rahe, aur jab antim samay aa gaya toh bol raha humko 2022 tak mahurat diya jai toh hum 50% double kar denge kisaano ka income. Kariban 40,000 kisaan khudkushi kar chuki hain, aur agar 4 saal mahurat milti hain toh 80 hazar ho jaegi .

Sir, Neeti Aayog ki barishta sadasya neh kya bathaya is bareh mein, mere pas document hain, aagar aap chahata hain toh dek sakta hain. Economic Times ke 31 January, 2018, Rashtrapati ke bhaashan 2 din baad Neeti Aayog ki barishta sadasya ka guest column nikla, “MSP is notified for 23 crops, but effectively insured only for two or three crops.” Dekhiye yeh kaisa dhokabazi hain, 23 fasal ke liya MSP declare kiya jata hain aur 2 or 3 fasal ke liye implement kiya jata hai. Isse bara dhoka bazi kisaanon ke saat nahin hua hai. He says “MP does not generate reasonable surplus income for the farmers, not surprising that the farmers are demanding effective implementation of MSP for all crops and keeping MSP 50% higher than cost.”

Economic Times ki ek report mere pas hain. Sir isme bhi kuch juglery hain aur falacies bhi hain, jaisa ki isme ek mechanism hain, CACP jo mechanism apnaya uske niyamo ke anusar 2 tarah ke cost assessment hota hain: Cost A2 aur cost 2. Cost A2 ke formula ke anusar fasal utpadan ke liye seed, fertilizers, manure, chemicals, human labour, bullocks, machine labours, irrigation expenses, and maintenance cost are the cost A2 mein ati hain. MSP cost A2 plus family labour, yani kisaan ka pariwar ke saat data hain , wo be jorta hain, uspar bhi 50% MSP rakha hain.

Tub bhi laabdayak hain, nahin toh nahin hoga, abhi toh khulasa nahin kya , Budget ko humne suna, kayan nahin baathaya gaya ke MSP kiski aadhar per tai ke gaya. Cost A2 or Cost 2, ahar Cost 2 hain, toh yeh dhokabazi hain. Sir social aur economic democratic ke gaya hain, chai registration ho , bus aada ho, havaee aada ho , sarak ho , jaan subdaya ho,har jaga , Swaach Bharat aur eak Bharat ka vishaal Bill boards hum deekta hain . Toh hali Pradhaan Mantree ji , annual Devos World ke meeting main gaya tha .Jab tak pradaan mantree paucha , tab tak international rights group ke jo ox farm kaya jata hain , woh ox farm ke report nakli aur usma kya batain gaya .

Ek line main bol na chahta hoon, quote “ India reaches to 1% garners 73% of the total wealth generated in the country in 2017”. Sarkar ke aane ke baad teen saal main Hindustan ka yeh chaihra hai, key 2017 main jo 73% wealth generate huwa who 1% ki kaabze main chale gaye, toh saab ka saath saab ka vikas nahi hai. Yeh 1% ke saath 1% ka vikas hai.

Sir, iss adhivasan main kala dhaan ke bare main kuch bhi nahi bataya gaya. Kyunki bolna kuch nahi hai. Ek RTI kiya kisi nagrik nai, Pradhan Mantri Ji ke daftar main bheja tha, saal bhar ghum te rahe who commissioner ke pass, information commissioner, aaj tak unka koi jawaab nahi mila, ki batao itne kala dhaan note bandhi ke baad Sarkar ke paas aiya, ek saal beet chuhka, koi jawaab nahi mila RTI application ka, jo gyar khanoni hai, penalty hona chahiye tha.

Kisne bolatha, agar hum bidesh se kala dhan laa ke, garib janta ki khate main 15 lakh rupeeya nahi jama karte hain, aur agar note bandhi ka shub faal nahi milta hai 6 maina main, toh hum chowrahe pe khare hone ki liya taiyar hai. Kisne bateya tha, main nahi bolna chata hoon, yaad delna chata hoon.

Pehle toh Panama papers nikle, 500 se adhik Hindustani ka naam aiya, phir pechle saal Paradise paper main 900 se adhik naam aiya. Yeh log toh swargwasi toh nahi hai, paradise paper main naam nikle mane yeh bharatiya hi hai, paradise main nahi rahte hain. Agar himaat hai toh white paper nikaliye, batiye, ki paradise paper main aur parama paper main jin Hindustani ka naam aaya hai hum unke khilaf yah caraway kiya hai, jaanta ko aap khulasa kijeya. Hindustan ka janta janna chata hai ki sarkar kyun khamoosh hai, white money ka liya humara maang hai.

Sir, PSU bank ke NPA ke bare main ek shabd nahi bateya giya iss adivesan main. Jo ki aaj yeh NPA 10 lakh crore tak pohunch giya hoga, us se bhi zaada. Agar sarkar mein himmat hain toh wilful default ko criminal offence aiylan kare, kahnoon main badlua laye. Will full default kab hot hai, keh humara pass humara capability hai phir bhi hum nahi deh rahe hai bank ko paisa wapaas, wohi will full defaulter hota hai. According to criminal law, this is the breach of criminal trust and … cheating, so till breach of criminal trust and cheating comes under the purview of criminal law, so aap IPC ko change kijeye, CRBC ko change kijeye, aur unke khilaf criminal proceedings kijeye, Special Court baniye, aagar himmat hain toh aap chu nahi sakte, kyunki yeh sarkar .. capitalist ka sarkar hai kisano ka, garibo ka, mazdooro ka sarkar nahi hai.
Sir, yeh rooz gar ke bare main bari bari shabth pehle bhi ki hai, lekehn Survey Date of The Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy ke unusar 2017 ke pehle 4 mahino main, 15 lakh mazdoor berozgar ho gaye note bandhi ke karan. This is the report of the Survey Date of The Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy, 2017. Sirf 4 mahino main 15 lakh bekaar ho gaye pechle saal, ab tak na jane kitne berozgar ho gaye who bhi note bandi ke Karen, yeh bata rahe hai hum nahi.

So yeh jumla ka fasana hai, hum ne wo purane geet suna tha Mukesh ji ka……..

Shankar Jaikishen aur Shailendraji ne likha tha
– “Kehta hain joker sara jamana, adhi haqueqat, adha fasana”. Yeh haqueqat se duur aisa ek fasana hain jo ki Jumla bhara huya ek fasana hain. Lekin desh ki janta isme fasna nehi chahte

Sir, adarniya Bitto Mantriji, Amritsar me chunao larr rahe the 2014 mein. Unh ape unone bola ki IT ceiling 2 lakh se 5 lakh karna parega. Isse 3 crore janta ko labh milegi. Unhone yeh bi dawa kiya ki agar IT ceiling nehi barte hain to trade aur industry barbaad ho jayega, aur isse karan, China aur Thailand Bharat se age bar gaye hain. Hala ki unhone haar gaye, lekin baad mein unhone 50 lakhs to baraya ceiling lekin baad me ek paisa bhi nehi baraya, is baar bhi nehi bara.

Sir, bitto Mantriji jo kuch bhi bola so bola, lekin abhi ‘cow vigilantism’, ‘love jihad’ shuru ho giye desh me. Ek shabd bhi is bhashan mein nehi hain, pakshme ya bepaksh mein. Hamara Bangal k eek mazdoor ko, kuthaar se mara gaya Rajasthan mein, aur uska baad usko jinda jalaya gaya, aur who tasveer social site me dikhaya giye video recrding korke. Supreme Court bol raha hain uyo social site mein nehi dikhana chahiye. Hum chahte hain ki uyo social site me dikhaye jaye, ta ki sara duniya dekhe Hindustaan mein kya ho raha hain. Kya yeh meri Bharat hain? Kya yeh meri Bharat hain? Go=rakshya ki naam pey hatya ho rahi har roj. Hum Republic of India mein hain yea Republic of Cow mein hain? Kya hum citizen of Republic of India hain yea citizen of Republic of Cow hain? Yeh sawaal banti hain.

Sir, mein antme Kaifi Azmi sahabka Chand Kaliya, jo ki Hemant Kumarji ne apnehi dhun mein ‘Anupama’ film me gaye the, wo mein bolna chahte hun

“Ek khawab khushi ka dekha nehi,
dekha jo kabhi bhul gaye abhi,
manga huya tum kuch na de saake, jo tumne diye wo sahne do,
keya dard kisika lega koi,
itna to kisime dard nehi,
behte hain asoon, aur behen do,
ab aisi tasalli rehne do.
Yah dilki suno duniyawalon.